Takeaways
#- PONY's first partial sale collected enough to cover the original position cost before the stock reversed.
- McLaughlin increasingly used resistance on the underlying stock to choose partial exits instead of a fixed option-return threshold.
- His NVT and SMCI examples showed planned profit-taking and a prompt exit from a failed debit spread.
- During the choppy market, he used some premium selling while emphasizing instrument choice and gap risk.
PONY felt like a losing trade by the time Sean McLaughlin closed the remaining calls on November 6, 2025. The stock had given back its breakout, a brief recovery had failed, and the final exit was below his original option purchase price. The whole trade was still profitable because he had already sold half near a resistance level identified in advance.
On the Live Options Jam Session, McLaughlin used that reversal to explain why he sometimes reduced a position before its trend ended. He also showed the cost of that decision: a partial sale would leave fewer contracts participating if the rally continued.
The first exit had a reason before the stock got there
McLaughlin said he had bought January $20 PONY calls for $2.25 on September 18. The stock broke out soon afterward. His plan called for selling half if the shares reached $24, an area near the earlier high where price had previously been rejected.
He was not trying to identify the exact top. He thought that level could interrupt the advance, even if the stock eventually broke through it. When PONY reached the area, he sold half the calls for $6.50.
The stock then reversed and continued lower. A bounce failed, and McLaughlin closed the remaining half for $1.45 after the trade reached its stop reference. He acknowledged that a tighter stop might have preserved more, but the earlier sale had already collected more than the original cost of the entire position.
That changed the economics of the disappointing finish. The weak final exit added to the proceeds from the first sale instead of turning the overall position into a loss.
Taking half off was a tradeoff
McLaughlin had once commonly sold half a position after doubling his money. By this episode, he more often chose a logical resistance level on the underlying stock. PONY illustrated that approach: the decision came from the chart rather than a fixed return threshold on the option.
He understood the objection. Selling half could reduce the payoff from the largest winners. In another account, he deliberately allowed positions to run without taking that partial profit. The corresponding risk was watching a large unrealized gain disappear.
Neither approach could be judged solely from the trade that happened to work best afterward. When he sold the first PONY tranche, he did not know the rally was ending. He knew only that the stock had reached a level where he had planned to reduce exposure.
NVT and SMCI showed two other exit paths
The NVT position had reached both planned profit levels quickly. McLaughlin checked his notes during the show and clarified that he had sold half when the shares reached $105, then closed the rest at $114. The second exit occurred on Halloween. He described the February $100 calls as a strong winner.
The SMCI trade had failed almost immediately. He corrected the entry date to Halloween and said he had paid $6.25 for a March $55/$85 bull call spread. After the stock fell, he exited for $2.86.
He had sized the position knowing the debit could be lost, but did not regard that maximum risk as a reason to hold until it disappeared. Once the trade stopped working, he preferred to recover the remaining value and move on.
A sideways market changed the portfolio's mix
The broader setting was frustrating. McLaughlin still considered the S&P 500's uptrend intact above its 50-day average, but recent breakout gains had been retraced and his shorter-term account had experienced repeated stopouts.
Asked about selling strangles, he said he had been using some delta-neutral premium selling as ballast during the sideways action. He favored liquid index ETFs and highlighted the risk of a sudden gap, particularly in individual stocks around earnings. He also explicitly noted the theoretically unlimited risk of naked calls. The position's structure and exit plan mattered alongside the market view.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2025-11-06 episode.
Why was $24 important to the PONY plan?
It was near an earlier high where the stock had been rejected. McLaughlin expected possible resistance or a pause there and planned to sell half, without assuming he could identify the final top.
How did the partial sale affect the PONY trade's result?
He said the calls cost $2.25, the first half sold for $6.50 and the remaining half sold for $1.45. The first sale had already covered the original position cost, so the later disappointing exit still left the combined trade profitable.
What was the cost of selling part of a winning position?
Fewer contracts remained to benefit if the trend continued. McLaughlin contrasted that with holding the entire position, which preserved more upside but exposed more of an unrealized gain to a reversal.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .