Takeaways

#
  • McLaughlin described SPX put butterflies centered about 5% below the market, with 100-point wings.
  • The butterfly’s highest expiration value occurs at its middle strike; a decline beyond the lower wing can leave the debit lost.
  • He closed losing Autodesk, Levi Strauss and EyePoint positions rather than relying on the hedge to repair those trades.
  • His SEI adjustment removed all short puts while retaining half the calls, and he raised the stop on the remaining Applied Digital position.

The VIX was rising again, even though SPY remained above the previous Friday's intraday low. Sean McLaughlin opened his October 16, 2025 Options Jam Session by asking what that divergence meant for a portfolio carrying high-beta positions and open profits.

He was not declaring an emergency. He was preparing for the possibility that a market decline could make it difficult to exit those positions at favorable prices.

His preferred addition was a put butterfly on the S&P 500 index, centered below the market. He paired that discussion with a less glamorous part of portfolio management: closing trades that had failed and raising stops on positions that had worked.

A butterfly aimed below the market

McLaughlin said outright index puts were one possible hedge, but rising implied volatility had made them expensive. He had not had much success using VIX or VXX calls himself.

Instead, he described buying SPX put butterflies. The structure combined one long put at a higher strike, two short puts at the middle strike and one long put at a lower strike.

He had been placing the middle strike approximately 5% below the index's level when entering the trade, with the protective wings 100 index points on either side.

For illustration, he used a 6,600 put bought, two 6,500 puts sold and a 6,400 put bought. Those were example strikes. He said the butterflies he had been placing cost about $3.50 per unit of option premium, or $350 with the contract multiplier.

The payoff depended on where the decline stopped

The structure's highest expiration value would occur at the middle strike. For 100-point wings, that value would be $10,000 before deducting the premium and costs. McLaughlin emphasized that finishing exactly at that point was highly unlikely.

The same payoff shape limits its usefulness as a hedge against a much larger collapse. Below the lower wing at expiration, the puts offset and the initial debit is lost. That is a feature of the long put butterfly structure, so the hedge targets a price range rather than supplying increasing protection all the way down.

McLaughlin described it as an imperfect hedge. He also explained why he hoped to lose money on it: a failed hedge could accompany a long portfolio that continued to rise. The premium was an expense he was willing to incur for the scenario he wanted covered.

Losing trades still had to be closed

Autodesk had fallen through his $310 stop. A subsequent bounce improved the exit, but did not restore the setup. He said the January $370 calls bought for $6.50 were closed for $2.75.

Levi Strauss had also failed. His calendar spread combined short November $26 calls with long January $26 calls. The short leg cushioned some of the decline, but he still closed the spread for $0.17 after paying $0.35.

EyePoint Pharmaceuticals was another immediate disappointment. McLaughlin said he exited for $0.85 after paying $2.10, and had to wait for a workable price because the bid-ask spread was wide.

Successful adjustments reduced what remained at risk

The SEI risk reversal had worked differently. McLaughlin had sold May $35 puts to finance May $60 calls, collecting a net credit at entry.

His plan called for selling half the calls if the proceeds could cover the cost of buying back all the short puts. He reported doing that, leaving half the calls open after removing the put obligation and retaining cash from the transactions.

A Constellation Energy put-credit spread had reached its planned exit. He said he collected $5.40 initially and paid $2.70 to close, capturing half the premium.

Applied Digital illustrated the tension in following a partial-profit plan. He had sold half the position for $8 after an entry at $2.65, then watched the stock continue higher. He wished he still held all of it, but the sale had followed the plan. For the remaining position, he raised the stock-price stop to $32.50 around a recent gap.

Questions and answers

#

Questions about the October 16, 2025 episode and the butterfly structure discussed.

Why did McLaughlin consider butterflies instead of outright puts?

He considered outright puts expensive after implied volatility rose. He used lower-cost butterflies aimed at a pullback toward a specific range, while acknowledging that the hedge was imperfect.

Link to this answer

What happens if the market falls below the butterfly’s lower strike?

At expiration, the put legs offset below the lower wing, leaving the initial debit lost. The structure’s protection is concentrated around the middle strike rather than increasing through an unlimited decline.

Link to this answer

How did he change the SEI risk reversal?

He sold half the calls and used the proceeds to buy back every short put. That removed the put obligation while leaving half the calls open.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .