Takeaways
#- McLaughlin chose Simply Good Foods for its weakness during a rising market, partly to balance existing bullish exposure.
- The gap below his original $22 stock target prompted him to take the put profits rather than demand a larger move.
- His reported option return applied to a position initially risking no more than 2% of the portfolio.
- Apple used a preset premium-reduction target, while Applied Digital combined an early partial sale with a raised stop.
Sean McLaughlin was looking for a strong finish to the market year, but his largest closed options winner had come from a falling stock. In the October 23, 2025 Options Jam Session, he reviewed his Simply Good Foods puts alongside bullish trades he had recently exited.
The combination was deliberate. He already had substantial bullish exposure and wanted a bearish position in a company showing weakness. Simply Good Foods had been making new lows even as the broader market advanced. It did not need an index selloff to keep falling.
The weak stock supplied its own reason to be short
McLaughlin had bought November $25 puts in mid-August. The stock initially moved against him for a few days, then resumed its decline. His original profit-taking reference was a stock price of $22.
On the day of the review, it gapped well through that target. He said he sold the puts for $6 rather than wait for an even lower stock price. The opening move had already delivered more than the plan required.
He described the gain on the options as roughly 1,200%, then immediately distinguished that figure from the return on his entire portfolio. He had limited the position's initial risk to no more than 2% of the account. The trade could make a meaningful contribution without having put the whole portfolio at stake.
The reason for the bearish position also mattered. McLaughlin had not been calling for a market collapse. He selected a stock that was weak in a strong environment, partly to diversify his existing directional exposure. The market kept rising and the stock still declined.
Apple was a smaller, preplanned premium trade
His Apple position used a different approach. During the October 10 selloff, he saw support near $240 and a rising 50-period moving average approaching that area. Higher volatility had also increased the premium available in November $235 puts.
He said he sold the puts for $4.65 with an order to buy them back after roughly half the premium had been earned. When Apple gapped higher on October 20, the position closed at $2.10, better than the approximately $2.30 he had been willing to pay.
McLaughlin presented this as a smaller, more routine profit objective than a large directional options win. He also emphasized that short puts could produce a significant loss and that he had kept the position small. The attractive premium did not remove the need to manage the exposure.
Applied Digital combined a partial sale with a later stop
In Applied Digital, McLaughlin had bought December $15 calls in early August. He sold half after the stock reached his initial objective, then left the remaining position open as the advance continued.
As the stock rose, he moved the stop reference higher. The remaining calls eventually came off after the stock closed below $37.50 and remained under that level the next session. He corrected the exit timing during the review to the previous day.
That sequence allowed the second half to benefit from more of the run while the earlier sale had already realized part of the gain. The final exit followed the updated price condition rather than an attempt to identify the exact high.
His market view still favored another advance
McLaughlin pointed to the S&P 500 and QQQ returning toward their highs, with the VIX falling back toward its summer range. He thought underperforming managers might have to buy stocks to catch up before year-end, and that the recent rotation out of some high-beta names could have cleared room for another advance.
He was preparing for that possibility while continuing to close positions when their individual plans called for it. Simply Good Foods supplied the clearest example of why the broad outlook and an individual trade did not have to share the same direction.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2025-10-23 episode.
Why did McLaughlin put on a bearish trade while bullish on the market?
He wanted some diversification against his substantial bullish exposure and selected a stock already making new lows. Simply Good Foods continued falling even though the broader market did not roll over.
What triggered the Simply Good Foods exit?
His original stock-price target was $22. On October 23 the stock gapped below that level, and he said he sold the November $25 puts for $6 instead of holding for a further decline.
How did the Apple and Applied Digital exits differ?
Apple was a short-put trade with an order to repurchase the options after roughly half the premium had been earned. Applied Digital involved a partial sale into strength, followed by an exit of the remaining calls after the stock lost the raised $37.50 stop reference.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .