Takeaways
#- McLaughlin’s long-option review showed why the size of gains and losses mattered alongside a roughly 26% win rate.
- Vertical spreads, calendars and credit spreads produced different payoff and timing trade-offs.
- The Hut 8 exit illustrated how a consistent risk rule could miss a later recovery.
- He expected market conditions and implied volatility to shape the next year’s strategy mix rather than copying the prior year mechanically.
Sean McLaughlin's biggest reported options winner of 2025 was a bearish trade in a rising market. He had bought puts on Simply Good Foods partly to balance a portfolio with substantial bullish exposure. The broader market did not fall, but the stock did.
That example gave his January 8, 2026 Options Jam Session review its central point: counting winning trades did not explain the result. The size of the winners, the losses accepted and the structure of each position mattered too.
McLaughlin compared several options strategies using his own trade records. His emphasis was on understanding how the results developed and deciding what to repeat when market conditions justified it.
A low win rate depended on sufficiently large winners
In his review of long calls and puts, McLaughlin counted 58 trades and 15 winners, a win rate of roughly 26%. The result depended on a small number of much larger gains offsetting many losses.
He was willing to lose the full premium on a long option. That possibility informed the position size before he entered. In the model portfolio he described, he risked no more than 2% of equity on an individual trade, sometimes less.
The Simply Good Foods position showed how an outlier developed. He selected a weak chart while looking for bearish exposure, bought puts and waited through a short period when the stock initially moved against him. The decline then resumed. After the October earnings reaction took the stock below his planned exit reference, he sold the puts.
He had not known at entry that this would become his largest winner. The reason for keeping room for large gains was precisely that he could not identify the eventual standout in advance.
Option structure changed the shape of the result
Long vertical spreads produced a different trade-off. Selling another option reduced the cost of entry, but capped the upside. Those positions could not produce the same open-ended gains as a standalone long call.
Calendar spreads depended more heavily on timing. McLaughlin wanted the nearer-dated short option to expire before a larger move benefited the later-dated long option. If the stock moved too quickly, the short leg could constrain the result.
He used First Majestic Silver as an example. After closing the short July option for a small amount, he retained the December call and participated in a later move. The sequence mattered as much as the initial bullish direction.
Credit spreads had a much higher win rate in his records, but that did not make them equivalent to the long-option trades. The amount at risk could be larger than the premium collected. Comparing win rates without comparing those payoffs would miss an essential part of the strategy.
An exit rule could feel wrong even when followed correctly
McLaughlin's Hut 8 example was less comfortable. He had a profitable long-call position, watched the stock weaken, and exited after the price action met his risk-management condition. The stock subsequently recovered to new highs.
He regretted missing the recovery while maintaining that the exit followed his process. A rule designed to limit damage would sometimes remove him from a position that later worked again.
His Coinbase review showed a more deliberate sequence: sell part of a position at a planned objective, then tighten management of the remainder as expiration approached. The plan did not require capturing every subsequent dollar of upside.
A viewer asked why he often waited for a closing-price signal and acted the next day. McLaughlin wanted the actual close, rather than a price just before the bell, and preferred avoiding a rushed option fill. He also acknowledged the trade-off: in many cases, exiting when the level first broke intraday would have produced a better result.
The next year did not require the same mix of trades
McLaughlin did not intend to choose strategies solely because they had worked in 2025. Sideways conditions could favor a different mix, while implied volatility would influence whether he bought an option, used a spread or considered selling premium.
He described the prior year's positive results across every strategy category as unusual. The repeatable part of his approach was the decision process: size the risk, choose a structure suited to the setup, define an exit and accept that following it would occasionally leave money on the table.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2026-01-08 episode.
How could a low options win rate still produce a positive result?
In McLaughlin’s reported trade records, a few large long-option gains offset many smaller losses. His position sizing allowed for the possibility of losing the entire premium on an individual trade.
Why did timing matter in his calendar spreads?
He wanted the nearer-dated short option to expire before a larger move benefited the later-dated long option. A fast move while the short leg remained open could constrain the gain.
Why did he wait for the closing price before some exits?
He preferred a completed daily signal and avoiding a rushed fill near the bell. He also acknowledged that waiting sometimes produced a worse exit than acting on the intraday break.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .