Takeaways
#- Gatlin expected silver to consolidate and wanted to distinguish a sideways pause from a deeper price correction.
- The SLV short-interest spike under discussion preceded the advance through 50; it was not a new bottom signal at record highs.
- The hosts saw potential for miners and industrial metals to broaden the commodity advance.
- Perz wanted price confirmation in oil or XLE before acting on the broader energy thesis.
Silver's powerful advance did not lead Sam Gatlin to expect a straight line higher. On the December 25, 2025 Christmas commodities livestream, he wanted to see how the market handled its next consolidation. A sideways pause would tell him something different from a deep decline.
Gatlin and Jason Perz joined Spencer Israel to discuss a commodity cycle they believed could broaden beyond precious metals. Their enthusiasm was clearest in the metals already showing strength. Energy remained a prospective trade requiring its own price signal.
Silver's next consolidation would test the trend
Gatlin thought silver had reached a point where a pause was reasonable. It was near the first Fibonacci extension he was using from the large decline between 2011 and 2020.
He distinguished a correction through time from a correction through price. If silver stayed near its highs and built a sideways continuation pattern, that would fit his interpretation of a strong primary uptrend. A much deeper decline, potentially toward the old 50 area, would provide different information about the strength of that trend.
He pointed to gold's repeated sideways consolidations as the pattern he preferred. Price had rested, then advanced again, while momentum avoided the deterioration he associated with a weaker market.
That framework left room for a short-term pause within his bullish longer-term view. The shape of the pause would help determine how quickly he expected silver to approach the next extension he discussed, around 111.
Positioning supported the view, but the earlier bottom had already passed
The hosts also discussed short interest in mining funds such as GDX and GDXJ, as well as the silver ETF SLV. Gatlin said elevated short interest had persisted during the advance and that earlier spikes in SLV short interest had coincided with useful turning points.
Israel asked him to clarify the timing. Gatlin was referring to an earlier positioning spike, around October or November, before silver cleared 50. He was not describing the current record-high price as a new bottom.
That distinction kept the observation tied to the sequence of events. The positioning unwind could still be helping an existing advance, while the immediate price was extended enough to warrant consolidation.
Miners and industrial metals offered different forms of catch-up
Gatlin expected mining equities to gain more ground relative to the metals. Although the mining funds he followed had performed strongly, he thought the miners could show greater relative strength as higher metal prices flowed into company results.
The discussion then moved beyond precious metals. Copper miners and steel stocks had already shown strength, and Gatlin saw aluminum stocks approaching a larger base breakout. He viewed that participation as evidence that the move was broadening.
Copper futures were especially important to his outlook. He saw a large accumulation pattern near a potential upside resolution, following a sharp earlier setback. The strength in copper miners supported his expectation that the underlying metal could catch up.
Perz similarly wanted copper miners and other commodity-linked groups on the watchlist for 2026. His macro view favored continued demand for metals, but their trading decisions still depended on price strength.
Energy had to earn its entry
Oil was the major laggard in the conversation. Perz expected energy eventually to participate, yet said he had not become aggressively bullish because the price had not confirmed that view.
Gatlin saw a slow downtrend in crude and a long-term area where former resistance was acting as support. He thought weak downside momentum could leave the market vulnerable to an upside squeeze.
Perz identified roughly 77 to 77.50 in oil and 50.50 in XLE as levels he wanted to see exceeded. He was prepared to act on either market's signal without requiring the other to move simultaneously.
Within commodity equities, Gatlin preferred the groups already working. He distinguished stronger metallurgical coal names from weaker thermal coal names. Perz agreed that familiarity with a company or success in a previous cycle was insufficient reason to choose it over current leaders.
Even repeated failed attempts did not remove a future trade from Perz's process. He emphasized waiting for another valid signal, sizing the risk and accepting that it could stop out again.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2025-12-25 episode.
What would a sideways silver correction tell Gatlin?
A pause near the highs could fit the pattern of a strong primary uptrend correcting through time. He wanted to compare that behavior with a deeper price decline before judging the next stage of the move.
Which energy levels was Perz watching?
He discussed roughly 77 to 77.50 in oil and 50.50 in XLE. He wanted a move above the relevant level and said either market could provide its own signal.
Why did the hosts favor stronger commodity stocks?
They wanted current price leadership rather than a familiar name that had worked in an earlier cycle. Gatlin used the difference between metallurgical and thermal coal stocks to illustrate that selection process.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .