Takeaways
#- Gatlin's silver thesis combined a long-term base with recent absolute and relative price strength.
- Perz remained bullish on energy's potential while waiting for crude and XLE to cross specified levels.
- First Solar's breakout was still a hoped-for confirmation, despite improving conditions across solar stocks.
- Israel's biotechnology question prompted an explicit discussion of overnight loss risk, basket size and trading horizon.
Jason Perz liked the commodity cycle he saw developing on Thanksgiving morning, November 27, 2025. Gold and silver had moved, copper had improved, and several resource-related equity groups were participating. Crude oil still had something to prove.
Joining Spencer Israel and Sam Gatlin for Stock Market TV's Thanksgiving special, Perz distinguished a market he expected to strengthen from a trade whose entry conditions had already arrived. Israel pressed him on the waiting: after months of discussing energy, when would he abandon the idea?
Perz's answer was that the outlook had not required him to buy an oil chart he disliked. He was waiting for price confirmation while trading other areas that were already stronger.
Silver's strength was visible across time frames
Gatlin wanted viewers to look beyond silver's recent advance. A quarterly chart showed a much longer base, which he interpreted as the beginning of a potentially substantial breakout. Perz supported using longer time frames to put an apparently stretched weekly move in context.
That perspective also required the ability to hold through volatility. Perz identified oversized positions as one reason traders struggled to stay with larger trends. A longer chart did not make the intervening price swings disappear.
Gatlin said silver had just closed at a record price and reached a new 52-week high relative to gold. He considered the relative move especially constructive because it suggested greater appetite for risk within precious metals.
Perz also discussed favorable year-end seasonality. That seasonal expectation supported his outlook, but the silver argument already included price strength he could point to in the completed session.
Energy remained a conditional trade
Perz saw improving shipping rates, refiners and other parts of the commodity market as reasons to keep watching energy. He nevertheless said crude oil had not yet made the move he wanted.
He identified $80 in crude futures and a move above $101 in XLE as important confirmation levels. Later in the discussion, he described a close above roughly $98 in XLE as an earlier improvement, with the higher level still ahead. These were proposed thresholds in the November 27 discussion, not reported breakouts.
His existing exposure also mattered. Perz said he had been buying selected international names and refiners that had performed well, while waiting before committing heavily to the large-cap energy group. A bullish commodity outlook did not mean he already owned every part of it.
He linked a stronger energy scenario to potential weakness in long-term bonds through TLT. He also acknowledged an alternative disinflationary scenario that could support bonds. The conversation treated those as competing expectations, with the price charts still unresolved.
Solar needed its own confirmation
Gatlin saw a developing recovery in solar stocks after years of weakness. First Solar, ticker FSLR, was central to his assessment. He compared its large base with the earlier Cameco chart, where a delayed breakout had eventually been followed by a strong advance.
The comparison explained what he hoped to see; it did not establish that First Solar had already completed the same move. He continued to describe an FSLR breakout as a potential trigger for stronger momentum across the solar group.
Israel noted that the solar fund TAN had held up better than he realized. Gatlin also liked SolarEdge, while acknowledging that the nearer-term path could be messy. The discussion's enthusiasm remained tied to a sector whose individual charts were still developing.
International markets added context to the commodity view
Perz viewed strength in Latin American equities, commodity-sensitive currencies and metals as related evidence. He expected the dollar's recent bounce to become a lower high within a broader downtrend. That was his currency outlook, not a settled result.
Gatlin highlighted Chile alongside copper miners outperforming the broader equity market. He favored countries with exposure to base and industrial metals, interpreting their strength as another part of the same cycle.
Biotechnology's rally did not remove its event risk
The holiday discussion also moved beyond commodities. Both analysts saw biotechnology's strength beneath the major indexes as evidence of risk-taking. Israel questioned whether high short interest might reflect knowledge about the underlying science that he did not possess.
Gatlin accepted the concern. He said a biotechnology stock could lose half its value overnight and described using smaller positions across a basket rather than concentrating in one name. He preferred assembling his own group, while discussing XBI as another way to obtain broader exposure.
Perz distinguished a trade lasting months from a promise to hold those companies for a decade. The bullish price patterns had not resolved the scientific uncertainty. That qualification gave Israel's question a concrete answer: participation in the rally still required decisions about position size, diversification and time horizon.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2025-11-27 episode.
Why was Perz still waiting on energy?
He liked several related commodity signals but said crude oil and XLE had not completed the moves he wanted. He discussed $80 in crude futures and $101 in XLE as important confirmation levels, with roughly $98 an earlier XLE improvement.
What role did First Solar play in Gatlin's outlook?
He saw FSLR as an important chart for the solar group. A breakout from its large base could, in his view, support stronger sector momentum, but he still described that breakout as a condition to watch.
How did Gatlin address biotechnology's risk?
He acknowledged that a stock could fall 50% overnight. He described sizing positions responsibly and spreading exposure across a basket, while Perz distinguished a multi-month trade from a decade-long holding commitment.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .