Takeaways

#
  • Thompson distinguished a structural concentration risk from evidence that the largest stocks were actually breaking down.
  • Rotation into smaller sectors could broaden opportunity while providing less support to the capitalization-weighted index.
  • He examined the seven dominant companies as a group alongside the major sector charts.
  • Breadth deterioration carried a different message when accompanied by weakness in the index's largest constituents.

Most stocks can rise while the S&P 500 falls. Most can fall while the index rises. For Larry Thompson, those apparently contradictory sessions were a reason to study the index's construction before interpreting its breadth.

In his August 22, 2025 Thompson's Two Cents episode, he called concentration the S&P 500's Achilles heel. The largest companies carried enough weight that weakness in them could overwhelm gains across many smaller constituents. Yet identifying that vulnerability was different from showing that it had become a problem.

At the time of the broadcast, he thought the evidence remained bullish. The biggest stocks were holding up, and participation elsewhere was improving.

Rotation could help stocks without helping the index equally

Thompson began with the weight of the S&P 500's major sectors. Technology and several other large groups dominated the index, while sectors such as materials, utilities and real estate accounted for much smaller shares.

That created an important distinction. A rotation from heavily weighted areas into smaller sectors could offer opportunities across the market while putting pressure on the headline index. The number of rising stocks alone would not show whether the gains were sufficient to offset losses in its largest components.

He made the concentration easier to follow with an equal-weight basket of seven major companies: Apple, Microsoft, Nvidia, Amazon, Alphabet, Meta and Tesla. Together, he said, those companies represented roughly one-third of the S&P 500 at that point.

The basket let him examine them as a group rather than assuming that one prominent stock represented all seven. Its recent pullback had held, price had followed through higher, and its relative strength index had remained above 50. He read that combination as buyers continuing to defend the dominant stocks.

The largest sectors were still contributing

Thompson then checked the sector charts. Technology was above a rising 200-day moving average and had turned higher after a short period that could have been mistaken for a developing top.

Consumer discretionary had produced a large up day, with Amazon and Tesla important to that group's weight. Financials had also broken higher after consolidating above support, while communication services had followed a breakout with a pullback and renewed strength.

He wanted to interpret those short-term formations within their larger uptrends. A pattern resembling a top did not persuade him to become bearish before price actually failed. He also argued that studies of chart patterns should account for the surrounding trend rather than treating every instance as equivalent.

Breadth became more useful beside the leaders

The equal-weight S&P 500 was reaching highs too. Thompson saw that as a second layer of support: the market's strength was extending beyond the companies with the greatest influence on the capitalization-weighted index.

His participation measures also showed improvement across time frames. He reported roughly 70% of S&P 500 constituents above their 200-day moving averages and a fresh expansion in the share above their 20-day averages. Longer-term trends and shorter-term momentum were moving together.

To explain why he did not use breadth in isolation, he returned to earlier periods. In parts of 2024, participation weakened while the major growth stocks kept supporting the index. The apparent divergence did not force an immediate decline.

Early in 2025, the combination was different. Breadth weakened, the largest stocks stalled, and then those leaders also became vulnerable. That was when the index corrected in his example.

Thompson therefore wanted to watch both pieces: the broad market and the companies carrying the most index weight. On August 22, both were supportive. A pullback remained possible, but the specific weakness he had described would require deterioration in the leading stocks rather than concentration alone.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2025-08-22 episode.

Why can the S&P 500 fall when most of its stocks rise?

The index weights companies by market capitalization. Thompson explained that losses in its largest constituents can outweigh gains in many smaller stocks, so the count of advances is only part of the picture.

Link to this answer

What kept Thompson bullish despite the concentration risk?

On August 22, 2025, he saw the dominant companies holding their trends, major sectors following through higher and the equal-weight index confirming the advance.

Link to this answer

How did he combine breadth with the largest stocks?

He compared participation measures with the leaders' price action. Weak breadth alone had not stopped some earlier advances, while weakening breadth together with vulnerable leaders had preceded a correction in his early-2025 example.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .