Takeaways
#- Barclays valued the 21 notes for redemption on June 7, 2023, and set June 14 as the payment date.
- Culley saw a much stronger rally in individual cattle futures than in the livestock note. The cocoa and sugar notes had tracked their market moves more closely.
- Coffee sellers and coffee futures have different exposures to bean prices. Culley’s 172-cent condition and 224-cent objective applied to the futures.
Spencer Israel noticed the ticker JO on Barclays’ redemption list. The coffee note had given him a way to follow the price of coffee on a stock screen. Ian Culley had traded JO before he even opened a futures account. Losing that ticker meant something different to them than losing a market they could still follow through futures.
On June 16, 2023, the two used What the FICC to look through the 21 iPath exchange-traded notes Barclays had called. An ETN is a debt obligation of its issuer, with a payout linked to an index. Barclays’ filing set June 7 as the valuation date for the cash payment and June 14 as the redemption date. The bank could retire its notes without a thing changing in the market for cattle, cocoa or coffee.
The cattle charts never told quite the same story
Culley had kept nearly the same caption on his COW chart for a year and a half: he was waiting for the livestock note to take out $40 decisively. Look at feeder cattle futures instead, he said, and a two-year climb was approaching the 2014 highs. Live cattle futures were making records. An investor following the livestock note alone could easily have missed the strength in those contracts. COW tracked a livestock subindex, not the price chart for a single cattle contract.
Cocoa was a different experience. NIB, the cocoa note, had risen alongside a rally in the futures. A friend who had owned NIB told Culley that he had received his payout but was sorry to lose a convenient way to trade the market. Culley still liked cocoa futures after their break above a decade-long downtrend. He also thought they were approaching his first target, where some consolidation would make sense. The sugar note, SGG, had likewise reflected a breakout Culley could see in the underlying sugar market.
Coffee futures and a coffee seller are different bets
For grains and soft commodities such as coffee, Culley generally preferred the futures themselves. A product that maintains exposure by rolling from one futures contract into another can behave differently from the single, most actively traded contract on a chart. Culley had seen stretches when that contract moved sideways while a futures-based product drifted lower.
Israel wondered about buying shares in a coffee business instead. A coffee seller pays for beans. All else equal, a higher input price can work against that business even as a trader who bought coffee futures benefits. That distinction mattered to the setup Culley actually wanted: coffee had broken below an earlier price level, recovered it and begun making higher highs and higher lows. As long as futures held above 172 cents a pound, he was looking for a return toward 224.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2023-06-16 episode.
Why could JO disappear even though coffee futures still traded?
JO was debt issued by Barclays and linked to a coffee index. Barclays exercised its right to redeem the notes. That ended this particular way of getting exposure to coffee without ending the underlying market.
What did Culley watch once the cocoa note was gone?
He continued to follow cocoa futures. He liked their breakout above a decade-long downtrend but thought the approach to his first target could bring a pause.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .