Takeaways

#
  • PBF Energy was back near $48.50 after a 7% decline, close to the highs it set in November 2022 and February 2023.
  • Israel said he tended to anticipate breakouts. Parets wanted the closing price before treating resistance as cleared.
  • Parets saw the area near $170 as potential support for L3Harris after about 18 months of declines.
  • Israel watched a gap near $500 to $502 in Lilly; Parets wanted the stock above roughly $590 before considering the long side.

The PBF Energy chart looked to Spencer Israel like a stock that had already cleared its old highs. JC Parets pointed to what was missing from the chart: that day’s trading. The New Jersey refiner was down about 7%, trading near $48.50. Add that quote to the picture and PBF was right back at the prices where sellers had stopped it twice before.

On the October 3, 2023, edition of Chart Request Live, Israel admitted what made the question interesting to him. When a stock gets back to resistance, he wants to buy it. He can already picture the breakout. Parets wanted to know whether anyone would still pay those prices at the close.

Where sellers had shown up in PBF Energy

The two earlier highs came in November 2022 and February 2023, around $48. Parets saw PBF working through the shares sellers were willing to offer there. A brief push above the line could mean buyers had absorbed that supply. It could also be a false start. With the stock back near $48.50 during the broadcast, he wasn't prepared to call it a breakout on the strength of the earlier chart.

Israel and Parets came around to two distinct entries. One was to buy at support, where a trader had some evidence that buyers had defended the price. The other was to wait for the stock to break above resistance. Buying as PBF approached the old high would put Israel in ahead of the very move he was counting on. Parets was particularly reluctant to anticipate that move in a market where, in his view, stocks were struggling to sustain breakouts.

L3Harris gave them a support test instead

L3Harris Technologies (LHX) was trading near $169 after falling for about a year and a half. On Parets’ longer chart, the area near $170 had acted as resistance in 2018 and subsequently as support. A buyer watching that area had a different question from the one facing Israel in PBF: would people who had bought L3Harris there before step in again?

Parets treated $170 as an area, so the quote around $169 was no automatic verdict. The long-term trend had been up, and after such a long decline this was a logical place to look for support. A decisive loss of that area would leave the chart open to more downside.

Two time frames put different prices on the Lilly chart

Eli Lilly (LLY) had traded around $600 three weeks earlier and was near $520 that day. On his daily chart, Israel could see a gap around $500 to $502. He wanted to know whether it could catch the stock. Parets agreed it was potential support. On his monthly chart, though, he was looking in the other direction.

Lilly had peaked in 2000 and didn't clear that peak until 2018. Once the stock rose above its old highs, there were no earlier trades at those prices to show where sellers might return. Parets projected levels from the size of that earlier correction. The rally had met one in the mid-$580s. A bounce near Israel’s gap could leave that obstacle intact; Parets wanted Lilly to clear roughly $590 before he would get interested in owning it.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2023-10-03 episode.

Why did the PBF chart look stronger than the live quote?

The chart Israel was looking at did not include that day’s selloff. PBF was trading near $48.50, close to the old highs it appeared to have cleared.

Link to this answer

Why was Parets watching $170 in L3Harris?

The area had been resistance in 2018 and later became support. With LHX near $169, Parets wanted to see whether buyers would defend that area again.

Link to this answer

Why did Israel and Parets focus on different Eli Lilly prices?

Israel was looking for possible support at a daily gap near $500 to $502. Parets used a monthly chart to identify overhead resistance in the mid-$580s, and wanted to see roughly $590 cleared before getting interested in a long position.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .