Takeaways
#- Parets treated Tesla’s roughly $190–$300 range as a trading framework after its strong early-2023 advance.
- For Nvidia, the historical $400-to-$500 rebound setup was separate from a breakout above $500 toward $750.
- Deere near $365 remained in the middle of its range, leaving both a potential top and a potential base unresolved.
- FirstCash’s relative strength interested Parets without requiring a recession thesis; $107 was a tighter reference than the broader structure near $90.
A viewer wanted to short Nvidia. Another was considering a short in Deere. JC Parets answered both requests by looking first at where the stocks sat within their trading ranges.
During the October 31, 2023 Chart Request Live with Spencer Israel, Parets saw a possible rebound trade in Nvidia and little directional clarity in Deere. Tesla, another request, was near the lower end of a range he had been following after its powerful early-year rally.
Tesla had room to breathe after the rally
Parets described Tesla’s advance earlier in 2023 as one of his best trades. He saw the subsequent consolidation in the context of that large move, rather than as sufficient reason to turn bearish.
His working range was roughly $190 to $300. With the stock near $200, he thought a long position could remain viable above about $190. The upper end was a different matter: he expected supply near $300 and would look to fade that area, at least initially.
Israel pointed out how the starting date changed the impression of Tesla’s performance. A strong year-to-date return could coexist with a stock that had made little progress since February. The January rally accounted for much of the difference.
That helped explain the trading problem. A stock could be a long-term outperformer and still spend months moving sideways between levels that mattered to a shorter-term position.
Nvidia offered a rebound and a separate breakout
The request to short Nvidia did not lead Parets to dismiss every bearish trade. He said the answer depended on the viewer’s time horizon. His own preference, however, was to consider the lower end of the range for a bounce.
Using the prices quoted in that October 2023 broadcast, he identified roughly $400 as the lower boundary and $500 as overhead resistance. A trade from $400 toward $500 appealed to him, provided the stock stayed above $400. Below that level, he did not want the long setup.
He preferred Nvidia even more above $500. A breakout there could open a longer-term move toward $750, in his analysis. Getting back to $500 and breaking through it were separate possibilities; he did not expect the resistance to disappear simply because the stock approached it.
Parets also compared Nvidia with the semiconductor group. Nvidia had already exceeded its late-2021 highs while the broader group was still struggling around that reference. He regarded the stock’s relative strength as encouraging evidence for a possible industry breakout.
Deere was in the middle
Deere was less decisive. Near $365, Parets placed it in the middle of its range. A bearish viewer could interpret the structure as a potential top; a bullish viewer could see a base that might eventually resolve higher.
He compared it with industrial stocks more broadly, which were also dealing with a range. Neither the individual chart nor the sector comparison gave him the clean directional resolution the question was seeking.
FirstCash already showed relative strength
FirstCash Holdings supplied a different example. Parets said the pawn-shop operator repeatedly appeared in his scans because it was making new highs and showing unusually strong relative performance.
He liked the stock above approximately $107, which could serve as a tighter risk reference. When he zoomed out further, he identified a broader structural level closer to $90. The two levels suited different amounts of room for the trade.
Israel asked whether owning a pawn-shop business was a recession bet. Parets pushed back on the need for that explanation. His interest came from the stock’s strength and its base, not from requiring a particular economic forecast to come true.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2023-10-31 episode.
What levels did Parets use for Tesla?
In the October 31, 2023 review, he outlined a range near $190–$300. He thought the long case remained viable above about $190, while the $300 area could attract selling.
How did Parets distinguish the two Nvidia setups?
At the historical prices discussed, he considered a bounce from around $400 toward $500 while the stock held above $400. He preferred a breakout above $500 for the larger potential move toward $750. Those were different entries with different conditions.
Why did FirstCash stand out from the range-bound stocks?
Parets said it was making new highs and repeatedly appearing in his relative-strength scans. He liked it above about $107, while identifying a more distant structural level near $90 on the longer-term chart.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .