Takeaways
#- Halliburton was gaining in dollars but had lagged SLB over the longer comparison. Its relative chart had improved in the preceding couple of months.
- Parets saw $55–$56 as a possible objective if Halliburton got through its old highs. SLB had already cleared its own.
- Cameco had broken out while Energy Fuels remained in a range. An improving Energy Fuels/Cameco ratio would suggest participation was broadening.
- NexGen was already clearing earlier highs when priced in Canadian dollars; Parets still saw resistance around US$6.50 on the U.S.-dollar chart.
Halliburton was pushing toward its 2022 highs. SLB had already cleared its own. Yet a viewer writing to Chart Request Live on September 19, 2023 saw Halliburton outperforming SLB. Could all three things be true?
JC Parets built the comparison while Spencer Israel and the audience watched. First came the Halliburton share price itself. A prior uptrend had given way to a base, and Parets thought a breakout could carry the shares toward $55 or $56, where they had run into resistance before. But that chart couldn't answer the part of the question about SLB. Both stocks could rise and a Halliburton shareholder could still have done better in the other one.
The lead depended on where the chart began
Parets divided the price of Halliburton (HAL) by the price of SLB, formerly known as Schlumberger. He plotted the ratio underneath Halliburton’s share price. A rising ratio meant Halliburton was gaining on SLB; a falling one meant an investor had been better off in SLB over that stretch, regardless of whether the two stocks were up or down in dollars.
In earlier stretches on his chart, Halliburton’s price had bottomed around the same time as its relative performance. More recently the lines had parted company: Halliburton was appreciating, but SLB had been the stronger stock. The viewer had spotted something real in the last couple of months, though. The ratio appeared to have found a low and had begun to turn up. That made a catch-up move in Halliburton plausible. Parets still wanted to see it get through its own prior highs; the improvement against SLB didn't clear that resistance for it.
A similar question in uranium
A request for Energy Fuels (UUUU) gave Parets another chance to put a smaller energy company alongside an established leader. Energy Fuels was still in a range. Cameco (CCJ) had already broken out of a base. When he divided Energy Fuels by Cameco, the resulting chart looked as though it might be building a bottom. If the uranium rally continued and broadened, smaller names might begin to outperform. That was a possibility the ratio let him monitor while the clearer breakout still belonged to Cameco.
The last uranium comparison didn't require two companies. A viewer wanted to see NexGen Energy in Canadian dollars. Parets first put up a monthly chart in U.S. dollars and pointed out that the current monthly bar wasn’t complete. Around US$6.30 to US$6.50, he still saw shares available for sale near the old highs. US$6.50 was his rough dividing line between a breakout and more trading inside the range.
When he switched to Canadian dollars, the chart was already taking out earlier highs. The company hadn’t changed between slides; the unit of account had. Someone buying NexGen with U.S. dollars could reasonably wait for an entirely different price signal from the one a Canadian-dollar investor was already seeing.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2023-09-19 episode.
How could Halliburton gain in price while underperforming SLB?
Relative performance depends on how much each stock gains or loses. If Halliburton rises less than SLB, the HAL/SLB price ratio falls even as Halliburton shareholders make money.
How did the viewer’s short-term observation fit the longer Halliburton chart?
The ratio had recently turned up from a potential low. That hinted at a catch-up trade while the longer comparison still showed SLB as the leader.
Why did NexGen show a breakout on one chart but not the other?
The Canadian-dollar chart had already passed former highs. In U.S. dollars those highs still lay around US$6.30–US$6.50. Exchange-rate changes can make the same company’s price history look different.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .