It pays to be an expert…
Earlier this year, social media was flooded with AI experts. A few months ago, it was geopolitical and oil experts.
Over the past few days, everyone is a market breadth expert.
I, for one, am not. Fortunately for me, I think JC and Steve are. And JC made the point this morning that we get periods of weak breadth all the time in bull markets.
Right now is certainly one of those times. The percentage of stocks in the S&P 500 trading above their 50-day moving average is roughly 25%, the lowest reading since April 1.
But if you zoom out, you'll see that these readings happen on a somewhat regular basis. As JC said this morning, the share of stocks above their 50-day drops below 30% once or twice a year.
He went back to 2003, when the S&P began a new bull market that lasted four years. Along the way, that breadth reading fell below 30% in 2004, twice in 2005 and again in 2006. The market didn't peak until October 2007.
"A baseball team wins 100 games, but in July, they go through a 4-game losing streak," he said. "Are you gonna fire the manager?"
Steve is a lot less worried about breadth than he is about bonds.
"The 10-year doesn't rip through 5% like this," he said. "This hasn't happened my whole career. I've never seen this happen."
And even JC admitted the last 2 days in bonds have been scary.
For the record, the 10-year closed at 5.11% on Wednesday, its highest level since 2007.
So in summary: Breadth? Not an issue. Intermarket behavior? Potentially an issue.
On Today's Morning Show:
- JC's favorite bear-market trade for his entire career, and why it doesn't work anymore.
- The market legend who retired before she could make her biggest call, so she made it anyway.
- Louie Sykes' one-line answer to "are tokens fake assets?"
- JC's new unusual beverage of choice for the mornings.
Questions and answers
#From the September 25, 2026 Daily Rundown.
Why did JC argue that weak breadth alone did not establish the end of a bull market?
He cited earlier advances that continued through periods when relatively few stocks were above their 50-day averages. The historical examples showed that a short-term participation setback could occur within a longer uptrend. The issue uses that context to question an automatic bearish conclusion.
What worried Steve more than the breadth reading in this issue?
He focused on the speed and significance of the rise in Treasury yields. Spencer contrasts the familiar occurrence of weak breadth with bond-market behavior the hosts found more troubling. Their concern was about the intermarket environment, not just the number of stocks above a moving average.
Originally published by Spencer Israel.