Takeaways

#
  • Elfenbein looked for overlooked businesses with zero, one or two analysts following them, then researched their operations and valuation.
  • His five annual additions spanned water service, agricultural lending, pest control, modular rentals and connectors.
  • Repeated guidance cuts could undermine his confidence that the original reason for owning a company still applied.
  • WD-40 narrowly missed the list because he preferred the valuations available elsewhere.

Eddy Elfenbein wanted to own businesses he could understand and follow for years. Some of his most interesting candidates attracted little attention from Wall Street analysts. On the January 16, 2024 Morning Show, he explained how that preference shaped his annual Buy List and the companies he chose to replace.

His approach required substantial company research. He read annual filings and kept track of businesses over time, including names that had previously appeared on his list. Low coverage made a company worth investigating; the business and its valuation still had to justify owning it.

Looking where coverage was thin

Elfenbein described zero, one or two analysts as the kind of sparse coverage that interested him. He believed investors were more likely to find overlooked bargains in that group.

He offered a possible explanation for the lack of attention: a company that did not need to raise outside capital or arrange a transaction might have less occasion to work with an investment bank. That was his interpretation of why some successful businesses remained underfollowed.

Miller Industries, the tow-truck manufacturer, illustrated his interest. He described a company that had delivered the strong year it had anticipated while attracting little analyst coverage. The hosts began discussing a possible screen for undercovered companies, with a market-capitalization floor to narrow the search.

Five additions and six departures

The new annual list included American Water Works, Farmer Mac, Rollins, McGrath RentCorp and Amphenol. Elfenbein discussed water service, agricultural lending, pest control, modular rentals and connectors, businesses with very different customers and sources of demand.

McGrath’s modular structures and rental operation particularly appealed to him. Amphenol was a former holding that he was bringing back, a reminder that selling a company did not permanently exclude it from consideration.

The departures were Carrier, Danaher, Middleby, Stepan, Trex and Veralto, which had been separated from Danaher. His reasons varied. Trex had enjoyed a strong run; repeated reductions in guidance had weakened his confidence in Stepan. Middleby had been on the list before, sold and then added again. He was removing it after a year whose performance had disappointed him.

Asked how he judged a holding, Elfenbein returned to whether the original business case still held. Repeated disappointments in management’s outlook made that assessment harder.

A good company could still cost too much

WD-40 had nearly made the list. Elfenbein liked the business but thought its valuation was too expensive relative to the alternatives available to him.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2024-01-16 episode.

What did Elfenbein mean by an undercovered company?

He described companies followed by zero, one or two analysts. He saw that limited attention as a place to search for bargains, with further business research still required.

Link to this answer

Which companies joined his 2024 Buy List?

American Water Works, Farmer Mac, Rollins, McGrath RentCorp and Amphenol. He discussed the different business models behind those five additions in the interview.

Link to this answer

Why did WD-40 miss the list?

Elfenbein said he liked the company but considered it a little too expensive. He thought other candidates offered better valuations at the time.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .