Takeaways

#
  • Akins wanted reported flows before evaluating demand for the newly trading ether products.
  • Growth in bitcoin ETF assets included price appreciation as well as investor flows.
  • His unidentified ownership category included retail investors and smaller advisers outside Form 13F reporting.
  • He distinguished isolated fund-liquidity problems from a claim that ETF flows explained the entire market’s behavior.

The first U.S. spot ether ETFs were beginning to trade when Mike Akins joined the July 23, 2024 Morning Show. BlackRock’s iShares Ethereum Trust (ETHA) was among the new listings. Akins expected an active session, but he wanted the flow reports before drawing conclusions about demand.

His work at ETF Action centered on the data beneath investment products: their holdings, valuations, exposures and ownership. The launch raised an obvious question for him. How much genuinely new money would arrive, and how much activity would represent investors moving an existing position between products?

Fund growth and fresh investment were different numbers

Bitcoin’s ETF launch earlier that year offered a comparison. Akins described continued inflows and a much larger pool of assets than at the January launch. He also pointed out that rising bitcoin prices had contributed to the increase in assets under management.

A larger fund balance therefore could not be read entirely as new investor demand. The value of an existing holding could rise without another dollar entering the product.

For ether, he expected movement out of Grayscale’s existing product to matter alongside subscriptions to the new alternatives. Whether that activity would be accompanied by substantial new money remained an open question. He did not treat the excitement of the first trading session as the answer.

The ownership chart had a large unknown portion

Akins then discussed his analysis of March 31 institutional holdings reports. Roughly 83% of spot bitcoin ETF ownership in that snapshot was outside the portion he could identify through Form 13F filings.

When the hosts pressed him on what that meant, he described a large retail component but also smaller advisory firms that did not have to file. The unknown portion was not a direct count of individual investors.

He contrasted that picture with the broader ETF market, where his team could connect a much larger share of ownership to reporting institutions. Early June-quarter filings were beginning to show additional bitcoin ETF holders, though many of the positions were small.

That left room for institutional adoption to expand. It did not establish that expansion would occur. Akins said the ownership chart could support different arguments about bitcoin’s prospects and declined to label the current mix inherently good or bad.

A familiar investment vehicle did not settle the asset debate

Akins remained skeptical of cryptocurrency as a long-term investment. Even so, he could see why an exchange-traded product appealed to institutions that wanted exposure. The investment vehicle and the merits of the underlying asset were separate questions.

He also emphasized the liquidity of what a fund owned. A product could attract enough money that its purchases became significant relative to the available trading in its underlying holdings. He recalled unusual cases in thematic funds where he believed flows had begun influencing those holdings’ prices.

He considered those cases a reason to examine the portfolio carefully, rather than evidence that ETFs as a whole controlled the stock market.

The rotation did not match a simple ETF-flow explanation

Asked about the sharp recent divergence between smaller companies and large growth stocks, Akins compared it with his flow data. Large-cap blend funds had still dominated the relevant U.S. size-and-style flows. Value had gained attention, but he did not see enough of an increase to explain the scale of the performance change through ETFs alone.

He distinguished that observation from his broader concerns about passive investing. Passive allocations also existed outside ETFs, and he thought their growth could prolong some valuation dislocations. That was a wider argument than attributing a particular week’s rotation to ETF purchases.

Akins expected consolidation among the many small products competing for assets. A fund could offer a useful tactical exposure and still struggle to generate enough revenue to maintain itself. He anticipated fewer thematic products but more assets concentrated in the survivors, with distribution and the ability to attract lasting investment helping determine which ones endured.

Questions and answers

#

Questions about the original 2024-07-23 episode.

Why did Akins separate fund assets from inflows?

Assets under management can rise when the investments already held appreciate. That increase does not require the same amount of new investor money to enter the fund.

Link to this answer

What did the large unknown portion of bitcoin ETF ownership mean?

It was the portion Akins could not identify through the March 31 Form 13F reports. He said it included retail investors and smaller advisory firms that were not required to file, rather than representing a direct retail-only count.

Link to this answer

Why did he question an ETF-flow explanation for the recent rotation?

His data still showed large-cap blend funds dominating the relevant size-and-style flows. He did not see an increase in value flows large enough to explain the sharp performance divergence through ETFs alone.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .