Takeaways

#
  • McLaughlin’s spreadsheet dated the Marathon call purchase to May 31. Buying puts as well was Parets’ original proposal.
  • A low share price limited how much a put could earn in dollars, even if Marathon suffered a large percentage decline.
  • Parets saw short covering as a possible source of demand if Marathon rallied. McLaughlin cautioned against dismissing the people on the other side.

Sean McLaughlin pulled up his spreadsheet to settle a question on the June 21, 2023 Morning Show. When had he and JC Parets bought calls on bitcoin miner Marathon Digital Holdings (MARA)? May 31, the sheet said. Parets remembered a detail that wasn't in the date column: he had originally wanted to buy puts, too.

Marathon had been trading in a tight range, and Parets expected it to break sharply. He had no particular conviction about which way it would go. Buying a call and a put with the same strike and expiration, a long straddle, would give him a chance to profit from a large move in either direction. McLaughlin agreed with the premise. Implied volatility was low, which made buying options more appealing to him. His objection came down to what the put could earn on a stock trading a little above $9.

What a drop to $3 could do for the put

McLaughlin rounded the stock price to $10 for his example. A trader could buy the $10 call and the $10 put. Or the trader could put the strikes outside the market, perhaps buying the $12 call and the $8 put. That second combination is a strangle. Both require paying two premiums. At expiration, the winning leg has to cover the cost of both before the trader has a profit. The Options Industry Council’s straddle example shows how those premiums move the two break-even prices farther apart.

Consider how far the stock would have to fall. A decline from $10 to $3 would wipe out 70% of the share price. The $10 put would have $7 of intrinsic value; the $8 put would have $5. Even a drop to zero would leave a finite number of dollars for the put buyer. A stock rising from $10 has no corresponding ceiling.

That arithmetic persuaded Parets to drop the bearish half of the trade. The calls alone cost less than buying both legs. In exchange, a sharp drop in Marathon would no longer help them. Their May 31 purchase was the calls, while the $10, $12 and $8 strikes were examples McLaughlin used to explain the choice.

What short sellers could add to a rally

By the broadcast, Parets was long both Marathon and bitcoin. He'd been watching bitcoin lag technology shares and saw room for it to catch up. During the broadcast, the panel received word of substantial short interest in Marathon. If the stock rose far enough to make some short sellers cover, they would have to buy shares. Momentum traders buying the same advance could add to the demand.

McLaughlin pushed back on the idea that those traders were foolish to be short. They often put considerable work into their positions, he said. Parets didn't need them to be wrong about the business for their orders to matter: once a seller decides to cover, the order that closes the short is a buy.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2023-06-21 episode.

Why did Parets first consider a straddle?

The shares had been compressed in a tight range. He expected a large move but didn't have enough conviction to choose a direction.

Link to this answer

How did McLaughlin distinguish a strangle from the straddle?

At a hypothetical $10 stock price, a straddle could pair a $10 call with a $10 put. His strangle example moved the strikes apart to a $12 call and an $8 put.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .