Takeaways
#- New highs in large-cap and small-cap value gave the hosts evidence of leadership beyond growth stocks.
- Reitmeister separated earnings growth from multiple expansion in explaining why he preferred smaller companies.
- BorgWarner and Autoliv illustrated his argument that lower rates could help both manufacturers and car buyers.
- He favored selected AI infrastructure suppliers while allowing that a rotation away from expensive leaders could be uneven.
Value stocks gave the Morning Show's technicians and its fundamental guest something to agree on. In the December 11, 2025 episode, JC Parets pointed to new highs in both large-cap and small-cap value. Steve Reitmeister arrived with a different form of evidence: a valuation comparison that made smaller companies look more attractive to him than the market's largest names.
The discussion, hosted with Spencer Israel and Steve Strazza, did not treat every stock as equally healthy. Oracle's sharp decline and uncertainty around AI spending ran through the show. The question was whether that weakness undermined the broader market or strengthened the case for looking elsewhere.
New highs had spread beyond growth stocks
The opening review emphasized the previous session's breadth after the Federal Reserve decision. The hosts described widespread industry-group gains and wanted buyers to produce a strong follow-through session.
The Russell 2000 prompted a disagreement about when to call a breakout. Parets emphasized successive record monthly closes; the exchange also distinguished those closes from the more immediate price breakout traders were watching. Both observations supported a constructive reading, but they referred to different time frames.
The value indexes supplied a clearer comparison. Large-cap and small-cap value had reached new highs in the charts they reviewed, while the corresponding growth indexes had not. The discussion connected that difference to sector composition, including greater financial exposure and less technology exposure in value.
That was a reason to examine the companies gaining strength outside the familiar large growth stocks, rather than assume the index headline described every part of the market.
Reitmeister saw room for both earnings and valuation gains
Reitmeister used forward price-to-earnings ratios to explain his preference. He defined the measure as share price divided by expected earnings over the coming year and argued that it suited a market looking ahead.
In his comparison, the largest companies carried demanding valuations, the broad large-cap market looked fully valued, and small and midsize companies remained more reasonably priced relative to their own histories.
He separated two possible sources of a stock-market advance. If a valuation multiple stayed unchanged, prices could grow alongside earnings. If investors also became willing to pay a higher multiple, the price gain could exceed earnings growth.
That second possibility formed his small-cap thesis. He expected investors to reassess companies that had lagged the largest stocks for years. Parets said the price evidence was leading him toward a similar conclusion, even though his method did not depend on the same valuation analysis.
Lower rates brought auto suppliers into the discussion
Asked where he saw opportunity, Reitmeister favored industrial businesses and, more specifically, auto suppliers. His reasoning linked lower interest rates to two potential effects: reduced borrowing costs for capital-intensive companies and more affordable financing for their customers.
He named BorgWarner, ticker BWA, and Autoliv, ticker ALV, as companies he found attractive in that environment. The hosts noted a classification wrinkle. Reitmeister was discussing their manufacturing economics as industrial businesses, while the formal sector classification placed auto-parts makers within consumer discretionary.
They agreed on the business mechanism without needing the category label to settle it. Reitmeister's argument depended on earnings performance and the possible benefit of lower financing costs.
He still wanted AI exposure through suppliers
Reitmeister's concern about expensive AI stocks did not mean he wanted to avoid every company connected to the buildout. He preferred some businesses supplying the infrastructure.
He singled out Tutor Perini, ticker TPC, within a discussion of specialty construction. He liked its valuation and growth, and emphasized that construction backlogs could give investors visibility into future work.
His concern was how much success the share price already demanded. A company could perform well and still disappoint investors if its valuation had assumed an even stronger result. That was why he distinguished participation in AI-related investment from paying any price for its most popular stocks.
The rotation case still allowed for turbulence
Oracle produced a more immediate disagreement. Strazza viewed its troubles as company-specific rather than a systemic market problem. Kenny Glick saw the weakness as supporting his desire for another selloff, though he also described switching from an intended short to a long when the prior session's price action reversed.
Reitmeister wanted money to move toward smaller companies and other overlooked groups. He also acknowledged that rotations rarely happen cleanly. His bullish case for those stocks therefore coexisted with caution about expensive leaders and the possibility of a less orderly transition.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2025-12-11 episode.
What did Reitmeister mean by a forward P/E ratio?
He described share price divided by expected earnings over the coming year. His valuation comparison used that measure to contrast the largest stocks with small and midsize companies.
Why did he discuss BorgWarner and Autoliv?
He saw them as auto suppliers with attractive earnings prospects. His thesis was that lower rates could reduce business borrowing costs and make financing a car more affordable for customers.
Did the panel agree on what Oracle's decline meant?
No. Strazza treated the problem as specific to Oracle, while Glick saw it as supporting a near-term bearish view. The broader value-stock discussion continued alongside that disagreement.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .