Takeaways
#- Parets owned the January $100 calls, which he recalled buying for about $1.20 a share. His near-term test was whether PayPal could stay above $67.
- McLaughlin was watching, not long. He wanted the stock above $70 after its rally toward $69 had faded.
- A call with months remaining could still lose the entire premium. Parets was prepared to abandon the setup much sooner if the old lows failed again.
JC Parets had bought January $100 calls on PayPal. The price he cared about that Monday morning was $67.
The shares had slipped below their lows from the previous year, recovered and briefly reached about $69. Now PayPal was trading near $67.40, back at the area it had just reclaimed. If the level held, Parets thought the failed breakdown could carry the stock back toward the previous August's highs. Another move below $67 would undercut his reason for owning the calls, even though they had months left to run.
Sean McLaughlin joined the June 26 Morning Show to clear up one question immediately: the PayPal trade belonged to Parets. McLaughlin had been following the stock but wanted it above $70 before he put money behind the idea.
Six months for the rally, a few days for the test
Parets had started by looking at the chart, not the options chain. Suppose the stock did get back to its August highs: how much time could he buy for that move? He found January calls with a $100 strike and recalled paying roughly $1.20 a share in premium. With the stock in the high $60s, those calls were well out of the money.
He thought owning the shares would have made for a simpler trade. A shareholder watching the old low could stay long above it and reconsider below it. The calls added a deadline and a price for the time. They also limited what he could lose if PayPal gapped down. As the Options Industry Council explains, a buyer can lose the full premium on a long call; the stock doesn't have to go to zero for that to happen.
Parets especially liked how soon he expected to get useful information. A drop back below $67 could change his mind that day or later in the week. If instead PayPal finished the week in the $70s, he could hold the calls and give the larger move time to develop.
Why McLaughlin was willing to pay up for confirmation
McLaughlin agreed that a reversal in PayPal could be sharp. But a bounce toward $69 followed by a return to the old lows hadn't yet shown him enough demand. Waiting for $70 meant giving up the first few dollars above support in exchange for evidence that buyers could carry the stock beyond its recent bounce.
They also disagreed about how much PayPal might benefit from strength in Bitcoin and the mining stocks. Parets thought a crypto rally could help a lagging payments stock catch up. Steve Strazza thought competition in PayPal's existing payments business mattered more; strength in crypto alone wasn't going to repair those losses.
Asked about the strike, McLaughlin said he usually liked buying calls around 25 delta because of their leverage on an advance and relatively low cost when he was wrong. That was a preference, not the way Parets had chosen the January $100s.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2023-06-26 episode.
Why did Parets buy a $100 call when PayPal was near $67?
He thought a failed breakdown could send PayPal back toward its August highs. The January call gave that move time, while $67 on the underlying stock told him when to reconsider.
What was McLaughlin waiting for in PayPal?
Parets was already positioned near support. McLaughlin wanted a move above $70 as evidence of buying strength and said he did not own PayPal.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .