Takeaways

#
  • Cerminaro’s breadth study treated the unusually widespread April 9 rally as constructive evidence over a six-month horizon.
  • The July 2022 example still included an almost 10% subsequent drawdown, showing why a favorable later result did not eliminate interim risk.
  • His price-and-earnings composite showed stock prices turning earlier on average, challenging the idea of waiting for every earnings signal to improve.
  • The discussion emphasized charts that made the time horizon, comparison and counterexample visible.

Matt Cerminaro brought an encouraging breadth study to the April 14, 2025 Morning Show. He also brought the column that complicated it: the declines investors had endured after earlier signals.

Cerminaro, known as Chart Kid Matt, joined JC Parets, Steve Strazza and Spencer Israel to examine the market’s rebound. His charts connected a sharp improvement in participation with later returns, then asked how much trouble could still occur along the way.

Broad participation made the rally worth studying

Cerminaro reported that 98.2% of S&P 500 stocks had advanced during the prior Wednesday’s rally. He searched back to 1990 and identified 15 previous instances of similarly broad participation, marking them on a long-term index chart.

The six-month results looked strong in his table. He reported an average gain of 13.3% and a median of 12.6%, while noting that some of the observations overlapped. He regarded the finding as a bullish piece of evidence rather than a reason to expect more downside simply because the preceding decline had been severe.

Strazza focused on a less comfortable example from July 2022. That signal had not prevented another leg lower before the October bottom. Cerminaro pointed to the drawdown column: the market had fallen almost another 10% after that particular reading.

The example separated two questions. Where the index finished six months later was different from what an investor might experience before reaching that date. A signal could be early, with a second low still ahead.

When asked whether the study meant buying everything, Cerminaro acknowledged that further weakness remained possible. He still considered the evidence constructive for a longer horizon. The discussion held both parts together: broad participation had improved, and the path from that improvement could remain rough.

High volatility also needed a time horizon

Another chart grouped observations by VIX level and compared them with subsequent six-month S&P 500 returns. Cerminaro’s point was that extreme fear had often coincided with stronger later returns in the history he examined.

He saw that chart as useful when an adviser spoke with anxious clients. It could put a difficult moment into a longer context without treating the immediate discomfort as the only information that mattered.

The horizon remained essential. His comparison concerned subsequent months, not a promise that prices would rise in the next session. The earlier drawdown example showed why a favorable later result could still include a painful interim decline.

Prices could turn before the earnings news improved

Cerminaro’s final market chart compared composite paths for S&P 500 prices and earnings during bear markets. By rebasing the series, he could examine where their respective lows occurred relative to one another.

He reported that prices had bottomed about nine months before earnings on average in that work. Waiting for earnings to turn upward could therefore mean waiting beyond the market’s initial recovery.

The hosts connected the chart with their own habit of checking price behavior after a headline. Cerminaro likewise viewed markets as anticipating later developments. His composite did not identify the exact date of an earnings bottom in the current episode, but it explained why improving prices could deserve attention while the fundamental news still looked weak.

The chart had to make its argument clear

Cerminaro also described his work on Exhibit A, a charting platform for financial advisers. He said the team turned raw data into charts that could support a client letter, a quarterly report or a conversation about investing. Some charts addressed recurring questions, such as purchasing power or drawdowns; others responded to events.

The market examples demonstrated that approach. The breadth chart included both later returns and intervening losses. The VIX chart specified a forward horizon. The earnings comparison made the sequence of two different lows visible. Each gave the audience a question to examine, rather than asking it to treat a rising or falling line as a complete explanation.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2025-04-14 episode.

Why did the July 2022 example matter?

Cerminaro’s table showed an almost 10% decline after that breadth signal before the later low. It demonstrated that an encouraging six-month outcome could still involve a difficult path.

Link to this answer

What did the price-and-earnings chart show?

Cerminaro reported that stock prices had bottomed roughly nine months before earnings on average in his bear-market composite. He used it to explain why prices could improve before the earnings news did.

Link to this answer

Did the breadth study rule out further weakness?

No. Cerminaro acknowledged that additional weakness was possible and noted overlapping observations in his study. He considered the reading a bullish data point for a longer horizon, not a guarantee of an immediate advance.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .