Takeaways

#
  • Christians distinguished an internal market low from the final low in the S&P 500’s price.
  • His study of simultaneous dollar and stock-market declines left a retest plausible despite the rebound.
  • Pessimistic surveys were not matched by equally extreme readings in every trading-based sentiment measure.
  • He looked for relative strength in technology and financials while allowing for a prolonged, volatile repair process.

Dean Christians thought the market had reached a tradable low. He was less certain that the S&P 500 had made its final low. That distinction shaped his appearance on the April 15, 2025 Morning Show with JC Parets, Steve Strazza and Spencer Israel.

The SentimenTrader analyst brought evidence of capitulation, deeply pessimistic surveys and historical rebounds. He also brought reasons to expect a retest. A strong recovery over six months could coexist with a difficult path over the next several weeks.

An internal low could precede the index low

Christians described an indicator that combined price momentum with market breadth. He had adapted a model shared by an anonymous market researcher, using subindustry data where sufficiently long individual-stock histories were unavailable.

The indicator had plunged during the selloff. To Christians, that supported a bounce and suggested that the worst deterioration beneath the index might have occurred. He called that an internal low. The S&P 500’s price could still fall further later.

He used 2022 to explain the distinction: market internals had reached an important low in June even though the index subsequently made a lower low in October. The condition of the underlying stocks and the level of the index did not have to turn on the same day.

He also explained why an annualized return displayed beside an extreme signal could look spectacular. A large one-day rebound, measured while the indicator was below its threshold and then annualized, could produce an enormous figure. It was not a forecast that an investor would earn that return over a year.

His practical expectation was more restrained. The capitulation evidence favored a rally, but oversold conditions could deepen before resolving. The initial rebound still left damaged charts to repair.

A falling dollar did not remove the risk of another low

Christians had examined earlier periods when both the S&P 500 and the dollar declined more than 7% over a rolling three-month period. He reported eight previous cases, six of which were followed by a lower S&P 500 low.

He highlighted an additional complication in one of the exceptions. In 1998, the signal had arrived during a retest rather than at the initial low. Where the market stood within the selloff mattered when interpreting the comparison.

Christians viewed the dollar weakness as investors bringing money back from U.S. markets during uncertainty. He did not interpret it as proof that the dollar was losing its reserve status.

The same research also informed his longer-term interest in technology. He said the sector had performed well a year after those episodes and pointed to large multinational businesses that could benefit from a weaker dollar. The possibility of later strength did not rule out another decline first.

Pessimistic surveys and actual trading told different stories

Christians saw a broadly gloomy mood, but not every measure showed equally extreme fear. Put-call behavior had been less pessimistic than he would have preferred. His comparison of value traded in leveraged long and short Nasdaq products also had not reached the extremes he associated with earlier major selloffs.

That left a tension between survey responses and trading behavior. Investors could describe themselves as bearish while continuing to buy declines. After years of being rewarded for that habit, he thought some were still inclined to repeat it.

He also connected damaged confidence with choppy prices. Investors needed conviction to commit capital; hesitation after a sharp loss could make the bottoming process uneven.

He wanted relative strength in potential recovery leaders

Christians considered a broad, volatile trading range plausible over the following three to six months. Progress on tariffs could help produce a rally toward its upper end. A loss of consumer confidence and slower growth could then contribute to a retest. Recession was not his base case at the time.

Within that range, he favored searching for offensive groups already showing relative strength. Technology was his principal area of interest for both the bounce and a more durable recovery. He also considered financial charts constructive and watched them for evidence of a larger systemic problem.

The selection mattered. He did not treat every beaten-down industry as equally attractive, and he was cautious about homebuilders while mortgage rates remained high. His approach required finding stronger stocks during the repair process, while leaving room for the index to revisit its lows.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2025-04-15 episode.

What did Christians mean by an internal low?

He meant the point of greatest deterioration in the market’s underlying participation and momentum. He explained that it could occur before the index reached its final price low, as in his comparison with 2022.

Link to this answer

Why did he still consider a retest possible?

His historical study of simultaneous dollar and S&P 500 declines included several later index lows. He also expected damaged charts and investor confidence to take time to repair after the initial bounce.

Link to this answer

Where was he looking for recovery leaders?

He focused on offensive stocks showing relative strength, particularly technology, and regarded financial charts as constructive. He was looking for stronger candidates within a possible trading range rather than assuming every weak industry would recover together.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .