Takeaways
#- Cappelleri watched a potential intraday cup-and-handle formation beneath S&P 500 resistance near 5,500.
- The higher low after the sharp rebound gave the recovery a possible foundation, while a bearish continuation remained possible.
- He allowed for sector rotation away from semiconductor leadership but considered continued absolute declines in SMH a threat to the broad market.
- VIX holding near or above its 40-week average would keep volatility risk elevated in his framework.
The S&P 500 had already staged a sharp rebound when Frank Cappelleri joined the April 16, 2025 Morning Show. He wanted to know what the market could build after it. Resistance near 5,500 was the immediate test; a higher low beneath that level could give the rally a foundation.
Cappelleri, the founder of CappThesis, discussed the setup with JC Parets, Steve Strazza and Spencer Israel. Daily charts showed enormous swings that could easily resemble bear-market behavior. A closer look at the intraday structure offered another possibility, but the potential base still needed to work.
A higher low mattered more than the snapback alone
Cappelleri compared the setup with late 2018 and early 2019. He remembered the powerful rebound from the December 2018 low and the reluctance to trust it. A potential cup-and-handle formation on a 60-minute chart had helped him recognize that conditions might be changing.
He saw a similar type of formation developing beneath 5,500 in April 2025. On the daily chart, that level looked like formidable resistance. The intraday view showed how the market might organize itself for a breakout.
The distinction was conditional. An advance through 5,500 could open a larger recovery, but he did not declare that the old highs would necessarily follow. Continued sideways movement could also develop into a bearish continuation pattern.
The pullback after the prior week’s large rally was therefore useful information. Cappelleri expected some retracement after such a fast advance. What mattered was that the retreat had produced a higher low, giving buyers a possible starting point for accumulation.
Parets connected that behavior to several markets holding near former cycle highs. Cappelleri agreed that those longer-term support areas mattered. He then wanted the shorter-term structure to show whether the recovery could develop beyond an initial bounce.
Which patterns worked could reveal the market’s character
Cappelleri tracked the success and failure of chart patterns as part of his assessment. He described a prior run of successful bullish formations, followed by failed bullish setups and then successful bearish ones. For the recovery to become more convincing, that sequence needed to change again.
This was also why he looked at more than one time frame. The long-term chart located important support; the shorter-term chart showed whether buyers were building something above it. Neither view supplied the whole answer by itself.
He used daily MACD as another example. During a persistent advance, bearish signals could repeatedly fail. In his comparison with 2022, signals in both directions had captured rallies and subsequent retreats. If both sides began working again, he would take that as evidence of a broader trading range or a more prolonged bear market.
Semiconductors could stop leading without becoming irrelevant
The hosts asked whether the broad market needed semiconductor leadership to return. Cappelleri pointed to the VanEck Semiconductor ETF, SMH, which had previously traded sideways while the S&P 500 continued higher. Other sectors could take a turn leading.
Continued absolute declines were a different problem. He did not think SMH could keep falling while the broad index sustained a strong advance. Large semiconductor companies still carried considerable influence in the market.
He also regarded SMH’s own short-term base as less developed than the S&P’s. Its pattern was wider and more volatile, and that morning’s weakness was damaging it. He wanted to see how those potential formations resolved as earnings approached.
Financials and industrials were other areas where he hoped to see constructive bases re-form. Rotation could support a recovery, but it had to appear in the charts. The possibility of another group taking over did not resolve the weakness already visible in technology.
VIX needed more than a retreat from its peak
Cappelleri’s volatility check used the VIX and its 40-week moving average. In the historical periods he highlighted, a spike followed by VIX holding near or above that average had kept risk elevated. By contrast, calmer advances had generally seen VIX below the average, with shorter-lived spikes.
He did not say that elevated VIX forced the S&P 500 lower. His concern was that wide price ranges made it harder to judge whether a durable base had formed. A more convincing recovery would combine successful price patterns with improving volatility conditions. Until then, 5,500 and the developing higher low gave him specific evidence to watch.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2025-04-16 episode.
Why was 5,500 important to Cappelleri?
He saw resistance there on the S&P 500 daily chart and a possible cup-and-handle base forming beneath it on a shorter time frame. Clearing it could support a larger recovery, but the breakout had not been established.
Did he require semiconductors to lead the next rally?
No. He said other sectors could lead while semiconductors stabilized. He distinguished that rotation from SMH continuing to decline, which he considered difficult for the broad market to overcome.
How did he use the VIX’s 40-week average?
He compared periods when VIX stayed near or above that average after a spike with calmer periods when it remained below it. Persistent elevation meant wider ranges and less confidence that durable bases had formed.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .