Takeaways
#- Ro linked the outlook for rates to the reason for the change: resilient demand could help earnings even as it delayed Fed cuts.
- The Magnificent Seven’s past contribution did not tell Ro which companies would generate the next round of index gains.
- An earnings beat measured results against an estimate. Ro compared the share of companies beating forecasts with the usual rate before judging an earnings season.
By April 2024 investors had begun to expect fewer interest rate cuts from the Federal Reserve. Sam Ro had a question about the change: Were companies likely to earn less money? If households still had jobs and were spending more than forecasters expected, he saw little reason to downgrade the earnings outlook just because the first cut might come later.
On the April 17 Morning Show, Ro drew a distinction between two reasons rates might stay high. Persistent inflation alongside a weakening economy would worry him. Companies would face high rates just as demand disappointed. But the economic growth, hiring and consumer spending he was seeing had all been stronger than expected. In that case the same evidence that weakened the case for rate cuts could strengthen the case for corporate profits.
What if the seven biggest winners stopped leading?
Ro had examined a similar argument about the Magnificent Seven in his April 8 TKer column. Those big technology stocks had accounted for much of the market’s gains and earnings growth. It didn’t follow that a slowdown in those stocks had to take the entire index down. Other companies could take their place.
Ro described himself as a bottom-up analyst. He worked from what companies could earn toward a view of the market. Over a day or two, he said, a reporter could attribute a rise to excitement about artificial intelligence and the next day’s decline to fading excitement about the very same thing. The direction of earnings gave him something he could follow across quarters.
Why were financial stocks falling after earnings?
JC Parets pointed out that financial stocks had been falling since the banks began reporting the previous Friday. How did that fit with Ro’s observation that roughly four in five companies reporting so far had beaten expectations?
Ro was looking at earnings across the S&P 500; financial companies had been expected to lag. He also thought the bar for a positive surprise mattered. By his estimate, about three-quarters of companies typically reported earnings above analysts’ forecasts. Reporting more than analysts forecast could say as much about where analysts and investor relations teams had set expectations as it did about the strength of a particular bank.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2024-04-17 episode.
Why did Ro emphasize earnings over the expected date of a rate cut?
He thought earnings had a closer relationship with stock prices over longer periods. Stronger jobs and consumption could support profits while reducing the need for monetary easing.
Which combination would have worried Ro?
He saw persistent inflation and high interest rates as more damaging if economic growth was also disappointing. Companies would then face pressure on earnings without the strength in demand he saw that April.
What did Parets see in financial stocks?
He said financial shares had fallen since banks began reporting, even as many companies beat estimates. Ro replied that financials were only one sector and that most companies historically cleared analysts’ forecasts.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .