Takeaways
#- Shapiro saw cocoa traders reducing long exposure during the advance, which kept him from shorting on price alone.
- A breakout can put pressure on traders who sold short into it. A market already crowded with buyers has a different mix of potential orders.
- He wanted both one-sided positioning and a confirming price move. A position could remain on his watchlist for weeks without meeting both conditions.
Cocoa had risen far enough to tempt a trader looking for a reversal. Jason Shapiro left it alone. On the April 26, 2024 Morning Show, he said traders had been selling into the advance. The price had climbed without attracting the crowded long position he would need to consider a short.
Copper offered a useful comparison. Shapiro thought metals positions were crowded, yet copper was still making a two-week high. Even there, he wanted price to turn before he sold short. If a market could keep rising while nearly everyone wanted to own it, identifying the crowd was only half the job.
Two breakouts, different buyers
Shapiro asked the hosts to imagine two markets with identical charts. One already had a large group of buyers committed to it. In the other, traders had sold short as the price broke higher. A further rise would put pressure on that second group: anyone who wanted out of a short would have to buy.
He contrasted Bitcoin’s breakout in early December with the Mexican peso’s more recent attempt. In his reading, traders had sold Bitcoin into the advance, which gave his process a buy signal. Peso traders, on the other hand, had already built a large long position before its breakout failed. Two similar-looking moves had met very different groups of traders.
By the April interview, Shapiro’s Bitcoin signal had been neutral for three or four weeks. The short positions that had interested him in December were gone. He didn’t need to turn bearish to move on from a long trade whose original reason had disappeared.
A crowded trade can stay crowded
Shapiro saw substantial short positions in the Swiss franc, Canadian dollar and Australian dollar. That put those currencies on his watchlist for a possible reversal against the U.S. dollar. It didn’t tell him when to buy. A shift in expectations for U.S. or European interest rates could change the trade, but he didn’t know which side of that comparison would move first.
Even his winning trades had followed no reliable schedule. Some squeezed immediately. Others began to move, stalled for weeks and only then resumed; a position might go nowhere for two months without hitting his stop. In cocoa, the positioning data earned its keep without producing any trade at all. It kept him from betting against a market solely because the price looked high.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2024-04-26 episode.
Why did Shapiro’s Bitcoin signal go neutral?
He said the large short position that helped produce the December buy signal had unwound. His process no longer had the same reason to be long.
What kept Shapiro from shorting copper?
He thought metals were crowded, but copper was still rising. He wanted the market itself to confirm a reversal before he sold short.
How did he approach heavily shorted currencies?
He watched the Swiss franc, Canadian dollar and Australian dollar for a turn against the U.S. dollar. The positions identified where he wanted to look; they supplied no entry by themselves.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .