Takeaways

#
  • Warder compared Alpha’s share price with the decline in coking coal from June 2022 to June 2023.
  • He attributed much of Alpha’s relative strength to its buyback after paying down debt. He disclosed that Alpha had been a client.
  • Warrior was investing in new supply at Blue Creek, a different use of cash from retiring shares.

When Matt Warder put the coal producers’ share prices on the same percentage scale, Alpha Metallurgical Resources stood out. It wasn’t enough to say that coal stocks had done well. What interested the Morning Show hosts on December 20, 2023, was why Alpha had done so much better than other producers selling into the same market.

Warder started with a stretch when the commodity and the stock stopped moving together. By his account, coking coal fell from about $600 a ton to $225 between June 2022 and June 2023. Alpha’s shares, meanwhile, spent much of that time trading sideways. That gave him a reason to look beyond the price of the next ton of coal.

What happened to the shares

Once Alpha paid down its debt, Warder said, it directed much of its free cash flow toward buying back stock. By the broadcast he estimated the company had retired roughly 30% to 35% of its float. Fewer shares were left to absorb new demand. He thought the buyback helped explain why the stock had held up during the decline in coal prices, then accelerated as buyers returned. Warder disclosed that Alpha had been a client of his at Wood Mackenzie.

A different use for a miner’s cash

Warder contrasted Alpha with another metallurgical coal producer, Warrior Met Coal. Warrior had two operating mines and was putting capital into a third, Blue Creek. In December 2023 he expected the project to begin contributing in 2025. Where Alpha was reducing the number of shares outstanding, Warrior was investing to increase the number of tons it could sell.

The distinction also mattered across types of coal. Warder favored coking coal, used in steelmaking, over coal burned in power plants. Abundant natural gas made him less optimistic about the near-term outlook for utility coal.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2023-12-20 episode.

Why did Warder compare Alpha with Warrior Met Coal?

Both sold metallurgical coal, but Alpha was buying back shares while Warrior was developing Blue Creek to grow production. Their exposure to the same commodity did not explain the difference in how they spent cash.

Link to this answer

Which type of coal did Warder favor in December 2023?

He preferred the outlook for coking coal used in steelmaking. He said abundant natural gas tempered his enthusiasm for coal sold to power generators.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .