Takeaways

#
  • The short-interest figure Parets brought to the meeting persuaded McLaughlin to add a June call to his original short-put idea.
  • The June $22.50 short put and $30 long call helped fund the January $21 protective put. The hedge expired months before the June legs.
  • The $21.50 level was an intended chart exit, not an option strike. At $30, McLaughlin planned to sell half the calls and cover the short puts.

Sean McLaughlin came to an analyst meeting with a modest idea for Chewy: sell a put and collect the premium if the stock held up. He was still bullish in the last week of December 2023, but less inclined to take a big swing than he’d been a month earlier. Then JC Parets told him that about a quarter of the shares were sold short.

McLaughlin didn’t take that figure as proof the sellers were wrong. What interested him was what they might have to do if the price kept rising. Buying stock to close losing short positions could add to the move. Selling a put alone would leave his potential gain limited to the premium, regardless of how far Chewy rallied.

Two June options and one January put

On the December 28 Morning Show, McLaughlin explained the position he had put on. He sold the June $22.50 put and used the proceeds to buy the June $30 call. Those two legs left a credit of roughly 28 to 30 cents. He spent 25 cents on a January $21 put expiring January 19. That left his initial cash outlay close to zero, although the short June put still required margin.

The expirations were deliberately different. McLaughlin believed a bad entry would probably show itself in the next couple of weeks. The January put offered some protection during that window. If he continued to hold the June position after January 19, that protection would be gone.

The strike and the exit weren’t the same number

The hosts stopped to check a detail: was his exit level $22.50? No. That was the strike of the put he had sold. The price he was watching on the stock chart was $21.50. If Chewy couldn’t stay above it, he said he intended to close the entire position, including the January hedge if it was still open.

He had a different plan if the stock reached $30. He would sell half the calls and use the proceeds to buy back the short puts, leaving some calls in case the move continued.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2023-12-28 episode.

Why did McLaughlin choose a January put to hedge a June position?

He thought a failed entry would probably become apparent within two weeks. He spent 25 cents on a $21 put expiring January 19 to cover some of that near-term risk.

Link to this answer

Was $22.50 his planned exit for Chewy?

No. The short June put had a $22.50 strike. McLaughlin separately identified $21.50 as the stock-chart level that would make him close the trade.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .