Takeaways
#- Strazza favored buying the earlier reversal and saw less room for a new trade near Uber’s old highs.
- He thought the index announcement gave an existing shareholder an opportunity to sell into demand. Parets put more weight on the price target.
Steve Strazza had owned Uber since the previous year. When the stock jumped on news that it would join the S&P 500, the prospect of finding new buyers made him think about selling. Uber was approaching a group of old highs, and the traders who had bought the reversal with him had already seen the stock reach two price objectives.
The announcement came on Friday, December 1, 2023. S&P Dow Jones Indices scheduled Uber’s addition to take effect before trading opened on December 18. On Monday’s Morning Show, Spencer Israel, JC Parets and Strazza discussed the roughly 5% jump they were seeing that morning, two weeks before the index change.
A different entry price made a different trade
The time to buy aggressively, Strazza said, had been when Uber was climbing out of its base. At that point buyers could watch whether the reversal held. By December, Uber was approaching prices where sellers had previously stopped its advance. He thought the stock might spend time working through that supply. He still liked its longer-term prospects if it cleared the old highs.
For someone who had held through the rally, the index news offered a chance to sell while others were eager to buy. Parets drew a distinction: he would consider selling because the stock was reaching the target they had set, even if no announcement had come out. That both things happened together was convenient.
Israel and the traders also considered whether joining an index made a stock more attractive over the following year. An index addition could create demand for the shares, but that was a different question from whether new members would outperform the companies dropped from the index. Parets wondered whether the stocks leaving might even do better. He said he hadn't run the comparison.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2023-12-04 episode.
When was Uber scheduled to enter the S&P 500?
The December 1 announcement set the addition for before the market opened on December 18. The hosts were discussing Uber’s initial reaction on December 4.
Why could Strazza still like Uber and consider selling?
He thought the stock faced sellers around its earlier highs after a substantial advance. An investor who had bought the reversal could take profits there while still seeing longer-term potential if Uber cleared that area.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .