Takeaways

#
  • Sohn’s historical comparison showed fairly ordinary stock returns at low VIX levels.
  • A VIX that rose to 25–35 and stayed there described a more difficult market in his analysis.
  • Strong stock returns associated with the highest readings can reflect rebounds from market lows.

With the VIX around 13 on December 5, 2023, Todd Sohn heard a familiar argument: investors had grown complacent, so stocks were due to fall. The first problem he saw was timing. Volatility would eventually rise from a low reading. A trader who acted on that fact alone could spend a long time waiting, as the quiet market of 2017 had shown.

On The Morning Show, JC Parets asked Sohn what was wrong with the indicator itself. Nothing, in Parets’ view: it measured the volatility implied by options prices. Cboe calculates the VIX from S&P 500 index options to estimate how much the index is expected to fluctuate over the next 30 days. It doesn't specify whether the next move will be up or down.

What changed when volatility stayed elevated

Sohn grouped historical observations by VIX level and looked at stock returns in each group. When the VIX was in the teens or lower, he said, the returns weren't particularly unusual. It was the combination of rising volatility and stocks beginning to struggle that warranted a closer look. A VIX that reached the 25-to-35 range and stayed there described a different market from one that had spent weeks near 13.

The highest readings presented another trap. Stock returns in that group looked particularly strong on the chart. Parets attributed much of that to rebounds from market bottoms, including 2009. As Sohn pointed out, living through the selloff that took the VIX above 40 was a different experience from owning stocks as volatility came back down.

Sohn offered a more useful reason to consider a hedge: deterioration underneath the major averages. If fewer stocks were holding up and the market's internal strength began to fade, an investor could act on that evidence. A low VIX by itself gave him no reason to assume those conditions were already in place.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2023-12-05 episode.

What does a VIX reading measure?

It summarizes the volatility that S&P 500 index options imply for the coming 30 days. The level does not say which direction the index will move.

Link to this answer

What would make Sohn consider a hedge while the VIX was low?

Weakening market internals would give him a separate reason to consider protection. He did not treat a low reading as a sign that a selloff was imminent.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .