Takeaways

#
  • Cox’s constructive outlook depended on the economy remaining solid as investors anticipated rate cuts.
  • She placed particular weight on initial jobless claims and wanted more detail on employment at smaller businesses.
  • Lower mortgage rates could help housing activity, but she would not assess falling rates without considering the labor market.
  • She regarded missing a market advance while heavily allocated to cash as a risk worth discussing with clients.

JC Parets wanted to know when falling interest rates stopped being good news for stocks. Lower borrowing costs could support the economy, but a sharp decline in yields might also reflect trouble that equity investors had missed.

Callie Cox’s answer on the August 22, 2024 Morning Show was to watch employment. The Ritholtz Wealth Management chief market strategist was encouraged by broader stock-market participation and improving earnings breadth. She still saw a path to a soft landing, provided the economy remained solid as the Federal Reserve moved toward the rate cuts investors expected.

Initial claims carried more weight than a single unemployment reading

Cox put particular emphasis on initial jobless claims. She viewed them as an early warning measure and considered claims relative to the size of the workforce, rather than comparing raw totals across very different labor markets. By that measure, she said, claims remained low.

The unemployment rate was rising, but she thought part of that reflected people entering the labor force to look for work. That was different from an economy shedding jobs aggressively. She also warned that the more benign explanation could deteriorate quickly, which made the mixed signals worth following.

Parets asked whether investors would be too late by the time employment data clearly weakened. Cox returned to initial claims, while also watching continuing claims and seeking more information about smaller businesses. A breakdown among smaller private employers would make her more concerned.

The question was whether the labor market was cooling without breaking. Cox thought the evidence still supported that possibility, rather than an immediate recession call.

Lower rates could reopen parts of the housing market

Cox did not offer a yield or mortgage-rate threshold that would settle the outlook by itself. A mortgage rate could fall for reasons that helped activity, or alongside an economy that was weakening. She wanted the employment backdrop to inform the distinction.

Housing was her practical example. High mortgage rates had discouraged both buyers and sellers. As longer-term rates fell, she thought more people on both sides could return to the market.

Parets pointed to homebuilders and real estate investment trusts making new highs despite the alarming commentary about property markets. Cox saw their strength partly as anticipation of lower rates. Prices were looking ahead, while much of the economic data described conditions already in place.

Strong retailers did not mean every household was comfortable

Parets also cited Walmart (WMT) and Costco (COST) as evidence against a collapsing consumer. Cox acknowledged the strength in those names and Target (TGT), while separating aggregate spending from the experiences of individual households.

Lower-, middle- and higher-income consumers were not all facing the same conditions. Those differences mattered to someone analyzing particular retailers, and they could become a broader problem if weakness spread. But she did not see the employment evidence as confirmation of the consumer breakdown some investors feared.

Cash had an opportunity cost, too

The conversation turned from the economy to how clients experienced risk. Cox said people readily imagined a market crash, but were less likely to think about missing an advance and having to buy at higher prices later. Being heavily positioned in cash could carry that risk even when the balance felt reassuring.

She understood why the early-August growth scare had unsettled people. She had received questions from friends about the volatility and thought the volume of alarming information could be difficult to absorb.

Parets approached that fear as a potential advantage for buyers: widespread caution could leave room for a rally, while complacency would worry him more. Cox agreed with the contrarian interpretation of sentiment. Her empathy came from the people behind it, including those asking what the selloff meant for their savings.

Questions and answers

#

Questions about the original 2024-08-22 episode.

Why did Cox emphasize initial jobless claims?

She viewed them as an early warning measure for employment and considered them relative to the size of the workforce. She also watched continuing claims and wanted more information about smaller employers.

Link to this answer

How did she distinguish helpful rate declines from an economic warning?

She looked to employment and the broader economy rather than choosing a single yield threshold. Lower rates could help housing activity, but deteriorating labor conditions would change the interpretation.

Link to this answer

What risk did Cox see in holding too much cash?

Investors could miss an advance and later need to buy at higher prices. She said that possibility deserved attention alongside the more familiar fear of a market decline, while recognizing that clients had different circumstances and experiences.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .