Takeaways

#
  • Brown contrasted commodity exporters Brazil and Russia with import-dependent India and China rather than treating BRIC as one trade.
  • A country’s largest listed company could be government-controlled. An index allocation could bring that exposure into a portfolio.
  • FRDM set country weights using freedom scores and excluded companies meeting its state-ownership threshold.
  • Brown found the market’s reaction to earnings more encouraging than the size of the earnings beats.

An investor who set aside money for emerging markets could own Indian and Chinese stocks through the same fund. In February 2024, Josh Brown saw money moving toward India while international investors were reluctant to add exposure to China. Being eligible for the same allocation did little to explain why the two markets should move together.

JC Parets put the question to Brown on the February 12 Morning Show: what was a financial adviser supposed to do with a single portfolio category when India, China and Brazil were behaving so differently? Brown started with the four countries that investors had once treated as a single growth story.

The commodity price on opposite sides of the ledger

In the original BRIC grouping, Brazil, Russia, India and China were all expected to benefit from a growing middle class. Brown thought that description left out a basic conflict. Brazil and Russia exported substantial amounts of energy and other commodities. India and China relied heavily on imports. A rise in the price of an imported resource was a cost for one economy and a source of revenue for another.

He could see why U.S. investors bought the group. Few would want to maintain dozens of individual country funds at fractions of a percent of a portfolio. But buying the group also meant accepting someone else’s decisions about which companies stood in for a country. A large listed oil or telecom business might qualify for inclusion precisely because it was one of the few companies of sufficient size. The government might also decide where that business could operate, what it could sell or how much profit it could retain. Its ticker told investors little about how much control shareholders actually had.

Changing the rule changes the fund

Brown and Parets discussed Perth Tolle’s Freedom 100 Emerging Markets ETF (FRDM) as a concrete alternative. Tolle started from a different question: what if the weight assigned to each country reflected the freedoms people had there? Brown cited religious freedom and the ability to vote among the dimensions that a country score could capture. A large stock market would no longer receive a large allocation solely on account of its size.

The fund’s January 2024 prospectus set out how that worked. The index set country weights first, using civil, political and economic measures. It then selected companies within the included countries and excluded businesses with government ownership of 20% or more. Brown liked the premise that greater freedom could benefit shareholders over long stretches. He cautioned that the relationship needn’t work every year.

In the U.S., Brown watched the reaction to earnings

Parets saw a similar gap between the headline S&P 500 and its constituents. The index had closed above 5,000, yet he counted nearly 60% of New York Stock Exchange stocks down for the year. His own March puts on the S&P and Nasdaq had suffered as the indexes climbed. Most of his bearish trades on individual companies, he said, were working or roughly flat.

Brown looked at how investors responded to earnings. Citing DataTrek’s assessment of fourth-quarter reports, he distinguished the number of companies beating estimates from the size of those beats: the first was around its long-run average, while the second fell short. Stocks nevertheless stood higher than when reporting began, and banks had held up. He thought the prospect that the Fed had finished raising rates mattered more to the rally than the precise number of cuts ahead. He had no position riding on what the Fed would do in March.

Questions and answers

#

Questions about the February 12, 2024 episode and FRDM’s index rules.

Why did Brown question a single emerging markets allocation?

The economies had different exposures. Higher commodity prices could help an exporter and hurt an importer, and their stock markets could move in different directions.

Link to this answer

How did the Freedom 100 Emerging Markets ETF choose its weights?

Its index assigned country weights from freedom measures before selecting stocks within those countries. It excluded companies with 20% or more government ownership.

Link to this answer

What mattered more to Brown than the number of Fed cuts?

He thought the fading risk of further rate hikes had benefited stocks. He said he had no trades based on the March policy decision.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .