Takeaways
#- Baiynd considered a downside butterfly centered on $650 and an upside one centered on $800, using the stock’s prices at the time.
- Her estimated cost depended on the actual quotes; she had already bought other Nvidia butterflies for later expirations.
- Strazza’s target from the $500 breakout had been reached. Dunuwila recalled a previous extension followed by roughly six months of sideways trading.
- Netto watched the short end of the Treasury curve for changes in traders’ expectations of a Fed cut.
Nvidia had reached the target Steve Strazza was watching from its breakout above $500. On the February 13, 2024 Morning Show, Anne-Marie Baiynd thought the stock looked stretched heading into earnings. She also remembered looking at the $600 calls earlier in the advance and deciding the shares could never get there.
That experience informed the trade she was pricing that morning. A pullback after the report was her first scenario. A rush of short sellers buying back shares could drive Nvidia sharply higher instead. Baiynd wanted to know what it would cost to have an options position near each of those possible destinations.
Two prices that would matter after earnings
On the downside, Baiynd estimated how far Nvidia had traveled from its previous trading range and considered how much of that distance it might give back. She used $650 as an example: a put butterfly with one $700 put, two short $650 puts and one $600 put. The $650 middle strike was where she wanted the shares to finish. A decline well past that point would be a different outcome from the one she was pricing.
The upside example centered on $800, with the outer strikes at $750 and $850. What interested Baiynd was a large move followed by a period when the stock settled near one of her middle strikes. Simply getting the direction right would tell her little about the value of either spread.
She was looking out to April for the put example. She had bought earlier Nvidia butterflies with time to run and said she already had positions for April and May. The roughly $10 she mentioned for the two new spreads together was an estimate; she was still checking prices. If the combination proved too expensive, she would consider narrower spreads.
A target reached and a trade still worth waiting for
Strazza thought the cleanest opportunity had come months earlier. Nvidia had consolidated after its August high and then broken above $500. It had reached the target faster than he expected. Another period of sideways trading could give him a fresh entry, much as the previous consolidation had. Where someone had bought mattered to whether taking profits made sense that morning.
Patrick Dunuwila later brought up Nvidia’s response to an earlier Fibonacci extension: the shares had traded sideways for roughly six months. He could see a pause at the new target as well. A further extension above $1,000 remained on his chart if the stock could get through the current level.
Baiynd had already spent about two months favoring smaller positions. She still wanted to buy pullbacks in leaders, but a break of a support area where the stock had spent considerable time would send her back to cash. A wide range of possible prices after earnings gave her a reason to compare the cost of the spreads, not a reason to increase her position.
Why the inflation release mattered on one trading horizon more than another
John Netto joined after the open. That morning’s Bureau of Labor Statistics release showed consumer prices up 0.3% in January and 3.1% from a year earlier. Netto thought the report, following a strong payroll release, made a March rate cut highly unlikely. For someone trading a three-to-five-day move, a single morning’s volatility could account for much of the range they had expected to trade. Someone holding for several months had a different decision to make.
When JC Parets asked whether bonds had been right, Netto asked which bonds he meant. He described short-dated bonds selling off faster than longer maturities as traders adjusted their expectations for Fed cuts. The ten-year yield alone couldn’t show that change in the shape of the curve.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2024-02-13 episode.
Why did Baiynd price two Nvidia butterflies?
She favored a post-earnings pullback but thought short covering could extend the rally. She wanted to compare the cost of positioning around $650 and $800.
What did Strazza want after Nvidia reached its target?
He thought the earlier $500 breakout had been the cleaner entry. Another consolidation could set up a new opportunity.
Why did Netto distinguish short- from long-dated bonds?
He saw the front end repricing the expected path of Fed cuts faster than the long end. Looking only at the ten-year yield missed that difference.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .