Takeaways
#- Walmart’s split would reduce its weight in the price-weighted Dow. Amazon was joining, but Walgreens, rather than Walmart, was leaving.
- Delwiche argued that investors following an index delegate constituent selection to its committee.
- Parets saw fewer stocks confirming index highs. Delwiche still saw more new annual highs than lows.
An investor following the Dow Jones Industrial Average could sit still in February 2024 and wind up owning a different retail business. Amazon was set to replace Walgreens Boots Alliance before trading opened on February 26. In the transportation average, Uber would replace JetBlue the same morning.
On the February 21 Morning Show, Willie Delwiche used the Amazon change to explain what bothered him about the word passive. The investor might never place an order, but someone had decided which company belonged in the index. Spencer Israel challenged him on the frequency: the industrial average hadn't changed constituents since August 2020. Did one decision in three and a half years really count as active management?
For Delwiche, the interval wasn't the issue. An investor following a 30-stock index owned a selection of companies. Whether the committee changed the list every year or left it alone for several, the investor had delegated the choice.
Why Walmart's split mattered to Amazon
Walmart was staying in the Dow. Its planned three-for-one stock split helped explain why a different retailer would leave. The Dow weights its holdings by share price. A lower per-share price after the split would reduce Walmart's weight, even though the split itself didn't reduce the value of its business. S&P Dow Jones Indices said the change would increase the index's exposure to consumer retail.
JC Parets saw Amazon as a natural choice for an economy so dependent on consumers. Steve Strazza and Parets also noted the timing: Amazon had already rallied sharply and Walgreens had already suffered a large decline. An investor tracking the index would pick up exposure to the first business and lose exposure to the second after those moves.
The best benchmark depended on the question
Strazza would readily quote the S&P 500 if someone asked how the market had closed. It was a useful approximation for investors whose portfolios leaned toward large companies. He had also worked at three equity funds where traders' compensation calculations used the S&P as the benchmark.
Ask how most stocks had done, though, and Strazza wanted a broader or more evenly weighted measure. A few large companies could dominate the S&P's return while hundreds of other names had a very different day. Delwiche saw that distinction working in investors' favor that February: even as some technology leaders weakened, he saw strength among industrials and broker-dealers, as well as in Japan and Germany.
Parets and Delwiche counted highs differently
Parets was watching the number of stocks reaching 52-week highs. The list had peaked more than two months earlier, he said, despite further highs in the major indexes. He also watched for more stocks to make 10- or 21-day lows. That deterioration had yet to show up.
Delwiche subtracted new 52-week lows from new 52-week highs. There were still more highs than lows, a reading that had kept him constructive about market participation. Parets objected that with so few stocks making annual lows, the subtraction wasn't telling him much he couldn't already see in the highs list. Delwiche cared about how the difference moved over time. A stock could qualify for the count on any trading day, even though the lookback covered an entire year.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2024-02-21 episode.
Which companies were changing places in the two Dow averages?
Amazon was set to replace Walgreens Boots Alliance in the industrial average, and Uber Technologies was set to replace JetBlue Airways in the transportation average. Both changes were scheduled for February 26, 2024.
Why did Strazza use different benchmarks for investors and stocks?
He considered the S&P 500 a useful reference for portfolios weighted toward large companies. To understand how most individual stocks fared, he preferred a broader or more evenly weighted measure.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .