Takeaways

#
  • Hurley saw a stretched S&P 500 but an apparently successful small-cap breakout, a combination consistent with a trading range.
  • After broad participation in December, fewer new highs alone did not persuade him that a bull market had ended.
  • During a volatility spike he watched the VIX against its previous three daily lows and five-day average rather than relying on a fixed threshold.

Apple made a three-month low just days after the S&P 500 reached a record. That looked like trouble for a market so dependent on a few large companies. On the February 27, 2024 Morning Show, Mike Hurley told JC Parets and Spencer Israel what would concern him more: seeing weakness spread from former leaders to the groups that had only recently broken out.

Hurley put the market in the middle innings of a bull cycle. He could see the S&P 500 going sideways for a month or two. The distance between the index and its 200-day moving average was about as large as it had been the previous July, before a correction. That told him prices were extended. It didn't tell him stocks had already begun to fall.

A slowing list of new highs

Parets pointed to an awkward feature of comparing February with the previous December: after a rally in which nearly everything went up, it was hard to get more stocks to participate. Hurley said measures of participation could peak well before the index. If he had called a top every time fewer stocks joined an advance, he could have spent much of a bull market waiting for it to end.

The previous year had offered a different test. Through the first half of 2023, the balance between 52-week highs and lows had swung to both sides of zero. Hurley had doubted the advance himself. He grew more confident when the S&P 500 cleared 4,200, then watched the market return to that area in October. By February, small caps appeared to have held a retest of their breakout, and biotech was showing strength. The largest stocks could slow down while participation elsewhere improved.

Parets raised a practical objection. Other sectors might attract buyers yet lack the weight in the Nasdaq or S&P 500 to replace lost technology gains. Hurley agreed: a healthier market for individual stocks could still produce a flat index. Healthcare, for example, had just broken out of what Hurley described as a three-year range. He wasn't prepared to dismiss it purely because healthcare often carried a defensive label.

How Hurley recognized the end of a volatility spike

Hurley also asked how Parets used sentiment. Both found extreme pessimism more useful than widespread optimism. The problem for Hurley was deciding when fear had actually peaked. A VIX reading of 20 could turn into 40; 40 could turn into 60.

A colleague's test used the shape of the move instead of a fixed number: wait for the VIX to fall below its lowest low of the previous three days. Hurley also watched whether it slipped below the simple average of its last five daily closes. He reserved those tests for a washout. With stocks near records in February, the evidence he wanted was damage in the stocks themselves.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2024-02-27 episode.

Why did Hurley think the S&P 500 might pause?

Its distance above the 200-day moving average resembled the reading before the previous July’s correction. A sideways period seemed possible even though he still regarded the larger trend as bullish.

Link to this answer

What did Hurley look for after a jump in the VIX?

He watched for the VIX to fall below the lowest low of the previous three days. A move below its five-day simple moving average was another sign the spike might be over.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .