Takeaways

#
  • Warder’s supply argument relied on limited mine investment, without requiring an exceptional demand boom.
  • He favored low-cost gold producers and identified Agnico Eagle and Lundin Gold as examples.
  • His coal outlook allowed for a 2025–2026 bottoming period before possible supply tightness later in the decade.
  • Cheaper computing could increase usage, but his uranium and thermal-coal cases still depended on power demand.

Matt Warder did not need an extraordinary surge in commodity demand to make his investment case. He was more concerned about the industry’s ability to supply even a modest increase.

On the February 6, 2025 Morning Show, Warder told JC Parets and Spencer Israel that too little financing for new mines had left parts of the commodity market poorly prepared for additional consumption. That was the starting point for his outlook across metals and energy.

Limited supply could matter before a demand boom

Warder resisted describing the entire opportunity as a commodity supercycle. The label suggested an exceptional burst of demand, while his argument began with years of insufficient investment in production.

Copper was one example. Electrification supported its demand outlook, but financing and bringing new mines into operation would take time. If consumption accelerated, producers could not immediately answer with more supply.

That did not mean copper could rise without encountering resistance from buyers. Warder thought prices around $5 to $5.50 a pound could encourage substitution toward aluminum where practical. He treated that range as a possible near-term restraint, even while remaining interested in the broader supply problem.

He also separated industrial commodities from precious metals. Different sources of demand and different investment cycles made a single timetable misleading.

Gold miners needed a cost advantage

Gold and silver were already prominent in Warder’s positioning. He said he had bought calls on the iShares Silver Trust the previous day, while continuing to favor precious metals as protection against sovereign and fiscal uncertainty.

For gold, his outlook included a move through $3,000 an ounce and the possibility of $3,500 by the end of 2025. Those were his expectations at the time of the broadcast.

When the discussion turned to mining shares, Warder preferred operators he considered to have low costs and strong management. He named Agnico Eagle and Lundin Gold. His reasoning was that a favorable operating cost position could allow more of a rising gold price to reach a producer’s margins.

Parets approached the same selection from the chart. Agnico Eagle’s strength near record highs stood out to him. Warder’s operating argument and Parets’s relative-strength observation supported their interest for different reasons.

Coal was a longer wait

Warder was less enthusiastic about the immediate pricing outlook for coal. He thought 2025 and 2026 could form a bottoming period, followed by tighter supply later in the decade.

That made the sector something to study before assuming a recovery was underway. He pointed to Alpha Metallurgical Resources and Warrior Met Coal among the companies to understand on the metallurgical side.

The power-demand thesis still had to survive new information

The recent DeepSeek news had challenged positions linked to growing electricity demand. Warder’s response was to revisit the underlying assumptions and size positions so that a sudden headline did not dictate the entire portfolio’s outcome.

He raised the possibility that cheaper computing could encourage wider use, leaving substantial demand for power even as individual tasks became more efficient. That was a reason to examine the demand path, rather than assume an efficiency improvement settled it.

The same dependency applied to his uranium outlook. Warder said weaker power demand would damage that case, and he connected thermal coal to the same question.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2025-02-06 episode.

Why did Warder hesitate to call it a commodity supercycle?

His argument centered on inadequate investment in new supply. He thought incremental demand could strain that supply without the exceptional demand surge implied by the label.

Link to this answer

What attracted him to Agnico Eagle?

Warder considered Agnico Eagle a well-run, low-cost producer. He wanted operating margins that could benefit from stronger gold prices. Parets separately emphasized the stock’s relative strength.

Link to this answer

Was Warder calling an immediate coal-price recovery?

No. He described 2025 and 2026 as a potential bottoming period and looked for tighter supply later in the decade. He suggested learning the sector and its companies while that process developed.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .