Takeaways

#
  • Conrad thought Abercrombie had widened its customer base while retaining younger buyers.
  • Store ownership gave a brand direct feedback on merchandise and inventory. Conrad liked a new store to repay its capital cost in roughly two years.
  • He attributed e.l.f.’s success mainly to wholesale distribution and its connection with young cosmetics buyers.
  • Arc’teryx’s premium jackets illustrated pricing power; summer merchandise was a separate challenge for its stores.

When Spencer Israel pulled up the monthly chart of Abercrombie & Fitch on February 9, 2024, he wanted to know what could possibly have happened to the company he remembered. Brett Conrad’s answer was that Abercrombie had once built an age limit into its own business. Its stores and advertising spoke to a narrow band of customers, roughly 15 to 25 years old. When shoppers aged out, they left.

Conrad thought the change behind the stock’s run was visible in the clothes. The company had moved on from the shirtless models at its doors and made merchandise that appealed to older customers without driving off younger ones. In his view, the old problem hadn’t been an inability to make merchandise at good margins. It was what happened to the customer after the first few years of buying it.

What a retailer learns at its own counter

JC Parets asked Conrad to distinguish a retailer from a brand. A company that designs a product and sells it in its own stores can decide how much inventory to carry and hear customers’ reactions directly from its salespeople. It can still contract out the manufacturing. For Conrad, the point of controlling the store was the short distance between the person choosing the inventory and the person watching it sell.

He also wanted evidence that the model earned back what it cost to open the doors. He followed book value per share and liked a new location to recover its capital investment in about 24 months.

Consider e.l.f. Beauty. Conrad saw most of its success on the wholesale side. The reason he liked what he saw was that young cosmetics buyers were choosing e.l.f.; he thought Estée Lauder had lost some of its connection with that audience. Abercrombie’s widening age range and e.l.f.’s appeal to a particular generation were different answers to the same question about who was coming back to buy.

What the brand name added to a jacket

Amer Sports had just brought another version of the question to the public market. The company, whose brands included Wilson and Arc’teryx, priced its initial public offering at $13 a share. Conrad was particularly interested in Arc’teryx. He knew the technical purpose of the waterproof, breathable membrane in its jackets. He also knew there were other materials available that did much the same job. What caught his attention was the price the brand could command: shoppers would pay $900 for a jacket, he said.

China offered a test of how far that appeal could travel. Conrad contrasted the pace of a company’s store openings with the work that preceded them. He described Lululemon developing its presence there slowly, testing a location before expanding. He saw promise in Arc’teryx opening premium stores, with one practical problem still to solve: a store built around winter outerwear needed something compelling to sell in summer.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2024-02-09 episode.

What did Brett Conrad think had changed at Abercrombie?

He thought the clothes could appeal to customers well past their mid-twenties. The earlier store image tended to lose shoppers as they got older.

Link to this answer

What did Conrad look for when a retailer opened a store?

He liked to see the investment in a new location paid back in about 24 months. Selling directly also gave the company timely feedback on what shoppers chose.

Link to this answer

Why did Arc’teryx stand out to him within Amer Sports?

Conrad saw buyers willing to pay a premium for its outerwear. For stores in China, he also wanted to see what the brand could sell outside the winter season.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .