Takeaways
#- Shull examined the expectations behind a trading reaction before treating it simply as a discipline problem.
- Expertise could create pressure to be perfect, making a familiar market harder for some clients to trade.
- She described FOMO as partly a fear of future regret and comparison with other investors.
- Her approach separated recognizing an emotion from allowing it to determine the next trade.
A trader can recognize a promising setup and still feel pressure for reasons that have little to do with the chart. Denise Shull’s work with portfolio managers starts by asking what those feelings are about. On the January 11, 2024 Morning Show, the ReThink Group founder explained how expectations about a trade can become entangled with expectations about oneself.
Professional experience did not eliminate that problem in the clients she described. Managers could be confident in an idea, see prices move against it and begin questioning their judgment. She wanted to understand the person’s working and personal circumstances before deciding what was driving the reaction.
The problem could be pressure to be an expert
Asked whether poor results usually reflected a lack of discipline, Shull resisted that explanation. She described experienced fixed-income traders who found currency trades easier to approach than trades in their own specialty.
Their expertise came with an expectation of getting things right. A currency trade felt more forgiving because it was outside the area in which they were supposed to excel. With one client, she worked on recognizing that his experience could help him see interactions earlier, instead of treating expertise as an obligation to be perfect.
She also acknowledged a limit to her observations: most of her clients had chosen to seek coaching. They were already interested in examining their decisions.
FOMO could be a fear of future regret
Shull described fear of missing out as partly an anticipation of how a trader might feel later. The imagined scene could be another manager talking about a profitable position while the person who missed it felt foolish or excluded.
That expectation could add urgency to a decision before the trade had happened. Her coaching sought to make those expectations visible so the trader could recognize what was contributing to the impulse to act.
JC Parets approached the discussion from the other side of the market: whose position was becoming uncomfortable? Shull suggested asking who would need to move prices further in the direction a trade required, and why those participants would act. New highs were one example she used to examine the different pressures on people already long, people wanting to enter and people caught short.
Boredom could consume attention as well as money
Shull recalled a midday trading restriction at her former Chicago firm. Quiet, rangebound sessions could tempt traders to manufacture a reason for a position simply because they wanted something to do.
The cost, in her view, included the mental effort spent managing those unnecessary decisions. Stepping away could preserve attention for a clearer opportunity later.
She distinguished feeling something from reacting to it. Rather than trying to erase every emotion, she encouraged clients to identify which feelings related to their market analysis and which came from elsewhere. Her example put confidence in a chart pattern alongside worry about a tax bill or a loss in another account: both could be present, without both having to determine the next trade.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2024-01-11 episode.
Why did Shull look beyond a lack of discipline?
She described clients whose mistakes were connected to pressure, self-expectations or an inaccurate reading of their own expertise. Understanding that context helped her examine why they were acting as they did.
How did she explain fear of missing out?
She connected it to anticipated regret, such as imagining another manager discussing a successful trade while feeling foolish for having missed it.
Did she want traders to remove all emotion?
No. She distinguished feelings related to market analysis from feelings about other parts of a trader’s life, and emphasized that noticing a feeling did not require acting on it.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .