Takeaways
#- Batnick saw broader participation and buyers stepping into declines as support for the market entering earnings season.
- He thought institutional money-market balances could reflect a fixed-income choice, rather than imminent stock purchases.
- Sentiment surveys were most useful to him at extremes; ordinary readings depended on which investors were being surveyed.
- He described Moderna as a trade and said a break below $100 that held there would cause him to exit.
Michael Batnick saw enough strength in the market to give the rally room to continue. More stocks were participating, buyers were stepping into declines and existing uptrends were holding. On the January 12, 2024 Morning Show, he said earnings season would test that picture as companies began reporting.
He also challenged a popular explanation for the next leg higher: the idea that money sitting in money-market funds would eventually have to buy stocks. His exchange with JC Parets turned on what that money was doing inside an investor’s portfolio.
Cash could belong to the fixed-income allocation
Batnick initially described savers moving from low-yielding bank accounts into money-market funds. Parets clarified that he was talking about institutional balances, rather than retail savings.
Batnick’s response was that those institutions might be using cash-like investments in place of longer-duration bonds. A yield around 5% could appeal to an investor who wanted income without accepting the price fluctuations of longer-term debt. In that case, a large cash balance would not necessarily be waiting to buy the S&P 500.
He also questioned what an aggregate dollar total revealed about portfolio weights. A very large total did not mean that any one investor had most of a portfolio in cash. He suspected those balances could remain there and leave slowly, while acknowledging that events could prove him wrong.
Sentiment mattered most at extremes
Batnick was selective about sentiment data. Different surveys captured different groups, and most readings did not tell him much. He preferred looking across measures and paying attention when expectations became unusually one-sided.
He interpreted the pessimism entering the prior year as part of the setup for the subsequent rally. Inflation had eased, the Federal Reserve’s hiking cycle had approached its end and the news had been less damaging than investors expected.
For early 2024, he would have welcomed a sideways market that absorbed the recent gains. Modest pullbacks and consolidation were his preferred path after strong advances and overbought readings.
A separate trade had its own exit condition
Batnick said he had recently bought Moderna. Parets challenged the choice of a stock that had been a laggard, and Batnick made the distinction between a trade and a position he would tolerate indefinitely.
If Moderna broke below $100 and stayed there, he said he would exit.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2024-01-12 episode.
Why did Batnick question the cash-on-the-sidelines argument?
He thought institutions might be holding money-market funds as part of a fixed-income allocation to avoid longer-duration bond risk. An aggregate cash balance did not reveal how much of each portfolio it represented or whether that money would buy stocks.
What market path did he prefer for early 2024?
He would have welcomed sideways trading and modest pullbacks that absorbed the prior gains.
What condition did he give for his Moderna trade?
He said he would get out if the stock broke below $100 and stayed below it.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .