Takeaways
#- Hirsch ranked the full-month January Barometer above the Santa Claus period and the first five trading days, while preferring agreement among all three.
- The Santa Claus measurement period was still running during the January 2 interview and would end at the January 3 close.
- He remained bullish for 2025 but identified the first and third quarters as potential trouble spots.
- He reported owning XES personally as a seasonal energy position, distinct from his research recommendation of XLE.
Jeff Hirsch did not want the first few sessions of 2025 to decide the year’s outlook. Asked on the January 2 Morning Show whether the Santa Claus rally or the first five trading days mattered more, he chose a third measure: the S&P 500’s performance over the whole of January.
The full month carried the most weight
Hirsch described the January Barometer as the central part of his three-indicator framework. Agreement among all three was his preferred outcome. Among the individual measures, he ranked the full-month barometer first, the Santa Claus period second and the first five trading days third.
The Santa Claus window covered the final five trading days of December and the first two of January. On the morning of this interview, it was still incomplete. Hirsch wanted to assess the whole seven-session interval, ending at the January 3 close, instead of drawing conclusions from its first day or a partial comparison.
He used the prior year to explain why the broader January reading mattered: a positive January could provide encouragement even when the shorter turn-of-year measures were disappointing. His January 2025 strategy note also set out the distinct measurement periods.
December’s weakness had made him more cautious
Hirsch still expected a bullish 2025, but he was less enthusiastic than he had been about 2024. The weakness at the end of December troubled him because it occurred during a period when his seasonal work normally favored strength.
He was comparing the recent pattern with 1968 and watching for broader participation, particularly from small caps. He treated that historical resemblance as a reason to check his optimism while continuing to examine current breadth and price action.
His principal concerns for 2025 were the first and third quarters. He thought the opening months of a new administration could bring uncertainty as policies changed, while the third quarter carried its own seasonal weakness. He still saw room for ordinary bull-market gains over the full year despite those difficult stretches.
Higher long-term yields were part of the concern
Hirsch identified the 10-year Treasury yield around and above 4.3% as an area he associated with more pressure on equities. He thought small caps were particularly sensitive to the rise.
JC Parets challenged the implication for Federal Reserve policy by distinguishing the long end of the yield curve from shorter maturities. The one-year yield was falling, he noted, while the two-year was not making new highs. The increase was concentrated farther out, in the 10- and 30-year maturities.
Hirsch acknowledged that distinction but continued to emphasize the 10-year as the benchmark he was watching. Steve Strazza then asked whether the problem was the absolute yield level or the pace of its increase. Hirsch described the relationship as imperfect and maintained that elevated long-term yields were contributing to the market’s hesitation.
He still expected the bull market to continue
Asked how far the bull market had progressed, Hirsch placed it in a later-middle stage and thought it could have roughly another year to run. His greater concern was the 2026 midterm year. That was his outlook at the start of January 2025, alongside the nearer-term risks he had already identified.
He remained interested in technology leadership and had also acted on a seasonal energy idea. Near the end of the interview, he said he personally owned XES, the SPDR S&P Oil & Gas Equipment & Services ETF. His research had also recommended XLE, but he had chosen XES for his own exposure because he thought it offered more potential movement.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2025-01-02 episode.
Which January indicator did Hirsch consider most important?
Among the individual indicators, he placed the full-month January Barometer first. He preferred confirmation from all three measures together: the barometer, the Santa Claus rally and the first five trading days.
Had the Santa Claus rally period finished when he appeared?
No. The interview took place on January 2, 2025, and the seven-session window ended at the January 3 close. Hirsch emphasized judging the complete period.
What was his outlook for the rest of 2025?
He still expected a bullish year, with more difficulty than in 2024. He was particularly concerned about the first and third quarters, while his larger midterm-cycle concern was 2026.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .