Takeaways
#- Dillian expected the next Fed meeting to test his bearish view and said he would cover if the thesis failed.
- His Blackstone short ran against the strength Parets saw in the broader capital-markets group.
- Parets distinguished internal market cooling from a confirmed larger decline in the indexes.
- Their disagreement extended to how they interpreted momentum and sentiment.
Jared Dillian thought investors had become too comfortable with rising stocks. He also had a clear condition for abandoning that view: if his thesis failed to play out at the next day’s Federal Reserve meeting, he would cover his short and move on.
That willingness to change his position shaped the January 30, 2024 Morning Show interview. Dillian expected a less accommodating message from the Fed than the market wanted and outlined the possibility of a six-to-eight-percent stock-market reversal. He recognized that his contrarian approach had not been working in the latest rally.
Blackstone put the disagreement in focus
Dillian disclosed a short position in Blackstone. He questioned its valuation and saw enthusiasm for private equity as evidence that the industry’s appeal had become widely accepted.
JC Parets challenged the choice. To him, shorting Blackstone meant leaning against strength across asset managers and capital-markets stocks. He asked whether Dillian expected Blackstone to weaken even if the rest of that group remained strong. Dillian said he did.
Their difference was partly methodological. Dillian often looked to sell stocks with compelling bullish narratives and buy those with the worst stories. He was interested in the point at which enthusiasm or pessimism became consensus. Parets wanted to know why that justified shorting a leader before its trend had broken.
Weakening breadth left room for two outcomes
Parets was already watching fewer stocks make new highs after the strong participation seen in December. He described a correction beneath the headline indexes, with defensive relative strength and currency moves adding to the picture.
The unresolved question was whether that internal cooling would lead to a larger index decline or simply give way to another advance. Parets said he was open to either outcome but needed to see the evidence.
Dillian also cited a divergence in the daily MACD momentum indicator. Parets questioned that reading because the indicators he was watching were still rising.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2024-01-30 episode.
What would make Dillian abandon his bearish position?
He said that if the thesis did not play out at the next day’s Fed meeting, he would cover and move on, allowing for further upside in stocks.
Why did Parets question the Blackstone short?
He saw strength across asset managers and capital-markets stocks. He asked whether Blackstone would diverge from that group rather than simply follow its rising trend.
What did weakening breadth mean to Parets?
He saw fewer stocks making new highs after December’s strong participation. He was watching whether that internal correction would become a larger decline or resolve with another advance.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .