Takeaways

#
  • The S&P 500 fell over the seven-session Santa Claus rally period. The first five trading days and the full month had not finished when Hirsch appeared.
  • Hirsch regarded a weak result as a warning. His base case on January 5 still called for gains of 8% to 15% in the major indexes.
  • His separate year-end trade looked for a rebound in stocks under selling pressure. It did not depend on a positive January Barometer.

The Dow finished the Santa Claus rally period up. The S&P 500 finished down. For Jeff Hirsch, editor of the Stock Trader’s Almanac, it was the S&P result that counted. But when he joined the January 5, 2024 Morning Show, only one of the three January readings he followed was in the books.

The first covered the last five trading days of December and the first two of January. The second covered the first five trading days of the new year. Those periods overlapped, and the second wouldn’t finish until Monday, January 8. The third, the January Barometer, measured the whole month. On that Friday morning, no one yet knew how either of the remaining two would turn out.

What would change his outlook?

Hirsch’s father, Yale, developed the Santa Claus rally indicator and the January Barometer. The first-five-days indicator was an older idea. Jeff explained why he had put the three together: over the years, he’d seen more profit-taking in January. He wanted to know whether the first few weak sessions were telling the same story as the rest of the month.

A positive January would still encourage him, even if the first five days also finished down. A loss for the month would make him more cautious about how easily the broad indexes could deliver gains. Neither outcome, he told the hosts, implied a 30% bear market. He was still working with an 8% to 15% gain as his base case for the major indexes in 2024.

A different January trade

Hirsch drew a distinction between the barometer and what traders call the January effect. The first uses the month’s index return as a clue about the year. The second concerns smaller stocks that have been sold heavily into year-end and can bounce when tax-loss selling eases. In his experience, some of that bounce had shifted into late December.

His year-end stock screen looked for common shares making fresh 52-week lows. In the basket he discussed, candidates had to trade above a dollar, average at least 50,000 shares a day over the previous 50 days and be down at least 30% from their 52-week high. One name on the list was 374Water (SCWO). Hirsch recalled checking his account at lunch and finding the stock up about 25% that day. He phoned his partner Chris and sold his shares at just under $2.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2024-01-05 episode.

Which three January indicators did Jeff Hirsch use?

The S&P 500’s return over the last five trading days of December and first two of January, its return over the first five trading days of the new year, and its return over the whole month of January.

Link to this answer

How did Hirsch distinguish the January effect from the January Barometer?

He used the barometer to interpret the full month’s index return. The January effect referred to seasonal strength in smaller stocks after year-end selling; he had seen some of that rebound occur in December.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .