Takeaways

#
  • Gordon already owned Tesla; Parets wanted to see the stock clear $300 before initiating a long position.
  • Tesla’s second-quarter revenue rose 47% year over year, but total gross margin fell from 25.0% to 18.2%.
  • Sokoloff reported trading around a Netflix short; she distinguished the result on the original shares from the gains on the whole position.

When JC Parets asked Todd Gordon if he was buying Tesla’s dip on July 20, 2023, Gordon answered a different question: he already owned it. He held shares in his wealth management business and had gone into earnings with options exposure. In his research, he had been following the stock from around $170. Parets had no position. At nearly $300, the two were making different decisions about the same chart.

Gordon was filling in for Steve Strazza on the Morning Show. Spencer Israel had pulled up Tesla’s results, which showed what the company’s price cuts meant for its margins. In its second-quarter update, Tesla reported that revenue had risen 47% from a year earlier while its total gross margin had fallen from 25.0% to 18.2%. The shares were trading below $300 before the opening bell.

An early entry changes the decision at resistance

Several features of Tesla’s chart put $300 in play for Gordon: a falling trend line from the all-time high, the area of the previous August’s high and the round number itself. He expected the stock to get through it. Someone who had participated in the advance could give it room to try.

Parets wanted buyers to prove they could absorb the shares for sale there. He had discussed the possibility of shorting Tesla below $300, but he hadn’t taken that trade. A breakout above $300 would make him interested in buying. The disagreement was over whether to carry a position into that test.

Who actually had a Netflix short?

Parets saw a similar obstacle in Netflix. At about $460, an area that had once supported the shares was now a place where he expected sellers. Below it he preferred the short side or no directional position. He gave that chart more weight than the increase in subscribers Israel had just described.

Kimmy Sokoloff, who joined later, already had a Netflix short. She had added to it after hours and covered part the next morning. Her original shares could still be showing a loss, she explained, even while the trades she had made around them put her ahead overall. She still saw a possible move toward $380. That longer view was one reason she kept some shares short after taking money off the table.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2023-07-20 episode.

Why did Gordon and Parets treat Tesla’s $300 level differently?

Gordon was managing an existing holding and expected a breakout. Parets was evaluating a new entry, which he preferred to make after the stock cleared resistance.

Link to this answer

How could Sokoloff be up on Netflix while her first short shares were down?

She added to the short and later bought back part of it. The gains from those trades could outweigh a loss on the shares she had originally sold short.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .