Takeaways
#- Franzen saw MSTR lagging Bitcoin on a relative basis after the ratio peaked in November 2024.
- Strazza expected a speculative catch-up phase, while Franzen emphasized vehicle choice and opportunity cost.
- Franzen liked software against the equal-weight market and did not require an immediate rate cut for his broader bullish view.
- Perz’s commodity-compression setup remained prospective, with stronger energy stocks and breakout levels on his watchlist.
Caleb Franzen remained bullish on Bitcoin, but he was less convinced that MSTR was the best way to hold that view. On the July 28, 2025 Morning Show, he showed a relative-performance chart that had stopped behaving as it did earlier in the cycle.
MSTR had tended to outperform Bitcoin when Bitcoin advanced from the 2022 lows and consolidate when it paused. By Franzen’s reading, the ratio peaked in November 2024 even though Bitcoin subsequently moved higher. He had already exited his MSTR position by an earlier February appearance on the show.
Steve Strazza took the other side of the relative-performance question. With speculative assets attracting attention, he expected the riskier Bitcoin vehicle to catch up. The disagreement concerned how to express a bullish view, rather than a shared expectation that Bitcoin was about to fall.
A calmer Bitcoin advance could favor a different vehicle
Franzen described Bitcoin as consolidating with an upward bias. It was making progress, but the advance was less explosive than some earlier phases he had tracked. In that setting, he thought a higher-beta vehicle such as MSTR could struggle to maintain its relative advantage.
He also saw more competition for investor attention. Additional Bitcoin treasury companies, new securities and Ethereum-focused treasury businesses gave investors more ways to pursue a crypto theme. The hosts discussed how MSTR’s earlier scarcity as an equity-market vehicle might be less valuable when alternatives were plentiful.
Franzen did not need MSTR to decline for that comparison to matter. His question was whether it offered the return and risk profile he preferred relative to simply holding Bitcoin. Strazza’s catch-up argument depended on a later phase bringing stronger demand back to the more speculative expression.
Software strength depended on the benchmark
Franzen applied the same comparative approach to equities. He liked software and cybersecurity and brought a chart of IGV relative to the equal-weight S&P 500 fund RSP.
That ratio had made a new high in his review. He contrasted it with earlier periods when weakening relative peaks had signaled less enthusiasm for the group. The current pattern supported his view that investors were still willing to own growth.
The comparison changed when he used the capitalization-weighted S&P 500 instead. Software had not yet reached the same relative milestone against that benchmark, which included the large influence of the biggest technology stocks. He saw the distinction as an allocation question: software could be beating the average stock without outperforming every index measure.
He did not require an immediate rate cut
Franzen also pointed to credit conditions and the performance of rate-sensitive equities. Stocks had continued higher even as expectations for near-term Fed cuts were pushed out. To him, that argued against treating the next policy meeting as the event on which the whole bull market depended.
He preferred long-duration risk assets rather than buying Treasury bonds to express that view. His focus was on the stock-to-bond trend, including SPY relative to TLT. He allowed for a consolidation or a retest of the breakout without abandoning the broader bullish interpretation.
Asked for his preferred trade into year-end, Franzen chose Bitcoin. He disclosed that it represented roughly 75% of his net worth and discussed a cycle projection of $175,000, potentially higher. Those comments explained how strongly he had positioned around his view.
Perz was watching a different unfinished breakout
Jason Perz later brought the commodity-compression chart that had briefly been attributed to Franzen by mistake. The distinction mattered because Franzen had explicitly said commodities were not his current area of focus.
Perz saw repeated Bollinger Band squeezes in the energy-heavy CRB index. Compression did not specify direction, but he interpreted it within a larger uptrend and was watching for an upward resolution. He was interested in energy leaders while still waiting for broader confirmation in oil and XLE.
JC Parets pointed to Imperial Oil’s existing strength. Perz agreed that leaders deserved attention and said he did not need to buy oil immediately. He wanted suitable stocks and breakout levels prepared for the point when the broader trade gave him a signal.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2025-07-28 episode.
Why was Franzen less interested in MSTR than Bitcoin?
The MSTR-to-Bitcoin ratio had weakened even as Bitcoin advanced. He also saw more competing crypto vehicles and questioned whether MSTR still offered the relative performance he wanted.
Why compare software with both equal-weight and cap-weighted indexes?
IGV’s strength against RSP showed performance relative to the average S&P 500 stock. The cap-weighted benchmark had more influence from the largest technology companies, producing a different comparison.
Did Franzen’s bullish stock view depend on the next Fed meeting?
No. He pointed to gains that had continued while near-term rate-cut expectations were delayed. He preferred long-duration risk assets and allowed for normal consolidations within that broader view.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .