Takeaways
#- Settle viewed a narrow pause near the S&P 500's old highs as a possible continuation pattern.
- He discussed roughly 6,500 while arguing that elevated long-term valuation limited the case for repeating the prior cycle's enormous advance.
- Microsoft's trend was already strong; Apple remained in a coil below its 200-day average and had yet to contribute a breakout.
- Thwaites used longer semiconductor charts to match reduced screen time and had reentered Advanced Energy Industries around its breakout area.
David Settle recognized the shape of the market's recovery on the June 11, 2025 Morning Show. The S&P 500 was approaching its earlier highs through a series of smaller daily advances, resembling a pattern he had studied from late 2023.
He thought the rally could continue. He did not expect it to reproduce the scale of the advance that followed the 2022 low. Speaking with JC Parets and Steve Strazza, he separated a constructive price pattern from the amount of upside he believed valuations could support.
A pause near the highs could be a continuation
Settle compared the current approach to resistance with the market's behavior around the end of 2023. In that earlier example, price had stalled in a relatively narrow range before continuing higher.
His point was that consolidation near an old high did not automatically imply reversal. A strong advance could slow down without becoming a substantial correction.
Parets asked how the rebound from pessimistic sentiment fit that view. Settle emphasized the recovery already visible in prices. He used the chart as his primary evidence and looked to other indicators to describe the move.
Valuation tempered the size of his forecast
When Parets pressed him for an S&P 500 destination, Settle discussed roughly 6,500. He considered a gain in that vicinity a good outcome after the difficult start to the year.
His restraint came partly from long-term valuation. He put the market's CAPE ratio around 37 and argued that the brief 2025 correction had not produced the kind of deeper reset that could support another exceptionally large advance.
He did not treat expensive valuation as an immediate sell signal. He thought bullish sentiment could still lift prices, while the starting valuation made him less willing to extrapolate the previous cycle's gains.
Microsoft was leading; Apple still had to emerge
Settle expected large and particularly mega-cap stocks to lead, rather than small caps. Microsoft illustrated the strength he had in mind. He highlighted the advance after earnings and a directional-movement indicator showing a strong trend.
Apple looked very different. Its highs and lows were narrowing into a coil, and it remained below the 200-day moving average. Settle thought an upside resolution could help carry the major indexes into their next advance.
Because Apple remained a large index component, he wanted to see it participate and recover at least toward the moving average. Microsoft was already demonstrating momentum; Apple's contribution was still a possibility he was watching.
A weaker dollar left room for disagreement
Parets viewed the earlier dollar decline as an accelerator of rotation from U.S. stocks into international markets. Settle agreed that years of U.S. outperformance and the valuation gap had created room for that rotation.
For the next phase, however, he expected U.S. stocks to do particularly well if risk appetite strengthened. Parets challenged that combination directly: U.S. outperformance alongside a weaker dollar.
Settle's answer returned to the large technology companies. He expected their weight and leadership to matter in a broad advance. Technology and semiconductors were his preferred areas for the second half of 2025.
Thwaites looked for chip exposure she could hold longer
Later in the episode, Mary Thwaites explained why she was spending more time on monthly and weekly charts. With her children home for summer, she had less ability to trade in and out quickly.
She liked SMH, the VanEck Semiconductor ETF, after its long consolidation and recovery. She also noted that the current monthly candle was unfinished. Her basket included both leaders and recovering laggards, including Nvidia and AMD.
Advanced Energy Industries supplied a more specific example. Earlier attempts to hold a breakout around $120–$125 had failed. She said she was back in as the stock held that area during the current week, with $120 as her reference. The longer base interested her, but holding the breakout remained the immediate test.
Questions and answers
#Questions about the original 2025-06-11 episode.
Why did Settle stay constructive while limiting his upside expectations?
He liked the recovery and consolidation near prior highs, but thought the short 2025 correction had not reset long-term valuation enough to support another advance like the one following the 2022 low.
What did he want Apple to contribute?
Apple was compressing into a narrow range below its 200-day average. He wanted an upside breakout and recovery toward that average to help the major indexes extend their advance.
Why was Thwaites moving toward longer trading horizons?
Her children were home for summer, reducing her ability to manage rapid trades. She was examining monthly and weekly semiconductor patterns and building a basket of leaders and recovering laggards.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .