Takeaways

#
  • Renick discussed owning Bitcoin while shorting Strategy, initially thinking about the pair as a hedge based on relative price sensitivity.
  • Parets cautioned that a premium to underlying Bitcoin holdings could persist and make the waiting period difficult.
  • Renick said using futures in the same direction as his existing positions added leverage and contributed to an earlier account loss.
  • His new business and changed income circumstances led him to reduce active trading after Bitcoin gains and dollar losses roughly offset.

Oliver Renick had an idea for expressing a view on Bitcoin without simply buying more of it. He also had a recent history of taking more trading risk than he intended. Both came up during his June 17, 2025 visit to The Morning Show.

Speaking with JC Parets and Steve Strazza, Renick returned to a discussion they had shared in New Orleans the previous month: owning Bitcoin while shorting Strategy, the company formerly known as MicroStrategy. The conversation moved from that relative-value idea to the practical problem of staying in a trade long enough for it to work.

Two ways to think about the same pair

Parets described Strategy's stock-market valuation as substantially greater than the value of its Bitcoin holdings. He connected the proposed pair with the approach attributed in their discussion to short seller Jim Chanos: buy the underlying asset and sell the more expensive corporate exposure.

Renick said his own thinking had started somewhere different. He was interested in the relationship between the two assets' price movements and whether a short position in Strategy could hedge some of a Bitcoin position's downside.

That left important implementation work. A valuation argument and a hedge based on relative sensitivity do not automatically produce the same position size or behavior. Renick was exploring the concept with people in the ETF industry, but he said packaging the trade into a fund was proving challenging.

He had a trade idea he wanted to develop. He did not present a finished ETF or a prescribed hedge ratio.

A premium could persist longer than a trader expected

Parets pushed back on the assumption that an apparent valuation gap would close promptly. Strategy had traded at large premiums to its Bitcoin holdings before, he said. The existence of a premium did not establish when it would disappear.

He brought up the historical relationship between 3Com and its Palm holding as an example of an apparent pricing discrepancy that took time to resolve. His point was about the cost of waiting: a trader could recognize a relative-value opportunity and still have difficulty remaining in the position.

Renick agreed that the trade might require patience. His interest in the pair did not settle the question of how it should be structured or how much adverse movement a holder could withstand.

Futures changed from a hedge into added leverage

Renick then described his own experience with macro trading. He had made money trading the interest-rate environment in 2022 and began using futures to hedge positions.

The next step caused trouble. Instead of using those instruments to offset risk, he started putting them on in the same direction as his existing trades. He recalled receiving a warning about the additional leverage and then losing the account around the autumn of 2023.

In his telling, he had also remained attached to the earlier interest-rate regime as conditions changed. A framework that had helped him in one period became difficult to leave behind.

His 2025 experience was mixed. He said Bitcoin trades had gone well despite his reputation as a crypto skeptic; he approached it largely through price action. Losses trading the dollar had offset those gains, leaving him roughly even.

Starting a business changed what he could risk

Renick said he had largely stepped back from active trading while starting a business. The reliable income that had once supported his willingness to speculate was no longer the same. He preferred to direct more of that activity toward poker, where he felt stronger.

Asked what connected poker and trading, he emphasized getting out of a pattern of losses and remaining profitable. He also distinguished the relatively contained poker table from the much larger field of market participants.

His own decision was concrete: after giving back his Bitcoin gains in the dollar, he was content to stop near breakeven and put his attention into the business he was building.

Questions and answers

#

Questions about the original 2025-06-17 episode.

How did Renick's Bitcoin and Strategy idea differ from a pure valuation trade?

He initially focused on how a short Strategy position might offset some downside in Bitcoin. The valuation approach discussed by Parets focused on buying Bitcoin while selling corporate exposure priced at a premium to the underlying holdings.

Link to this answer

Why might the pair require patience?

Parets pointed out that Strategy's premium had persisted through different market conditions. A perceived pricing discrepancy did not identify a date when the two sides would converge.

Link to this answer

What went wrong when Renick started using futures?

He said he moved from using futures as hedges to adding positions in the same direction as his existing trades. That increased leverage while he remained attached to an earlier interest-rate framework, and he recalled losing the account in 2023.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .