Takeaways

#
  • Nicoski said narrowing breadth could coexist with further market gains.
  • A one-day rise in weak stocks did not repair their downtrends; he wanted several days of follow-through.
  • He distinguished strength in retailers selling necessities from broader strength across consumer groups.
  • For energy, he wanted a change in direction on the charts rather than relying on a low historical sector weight.

Narrowing market breadth did not tell David Nicoski that stocks had to fall. Some powerful advances, he noted, had occurred with fewer stocks participating. His question on the June 21, 2024 Morning Show was whether money leaving technology would begin to support other parts of the market.

He had seen an early hint the previous day: several stocks his firm had identified as short candidates rose while technology fell. But those gains had not repaired their charts. They were still in downtrends.

An uptick needed follow-through

Nicoski wanted two or three days of evidence before treating the move as rotation. He had also noticed hammer-shaped candles in energy stocks, but would not make a call from one pattern. The next several sessions would show whether buyers followed through.

He was concerned about concentration in technology and saw the possibility that even a modest shift away from its largest companies could matter to smaller areas of the market. Yet he did not see the same breadth divergences that had preceded the small-cap rally he discussed from autumn 2023. The latest improvement was incremental.

His interest in natural resources did not amount to a blanket preference for materials. He said his firm had become positive on aluminum stocks roughly four months earlier, pointing to Alcoa and Century Aluminum, and he still liked the aluminum group. He did not like the broader materials sector at that moment.

A few retailers did not settle the consumer question

Nicoski also questioned using strength in Costco and Walmart as proof that the consumer was broadly strong. Those businesses supplied everyday needs. He contrasted them with weakness in purchases such as boats, recreational vehicles and furniture.

The dispersion mattered to him. One restaurant making new highs could coexist with several others making new lows. He wanted a majority of stocks in a group improving before describing that group as strong.

The direction of change mattered more than an average

When the conversation returned to energy, Nicoski distinguished a sector’s historical weight from a signal to buy it. Being below an average allocation was not enough. He cared about whether energy’s share of the market was rising or falling and wanted the charts to show an inflection.

He described himself as more defensive and still looking for opportunities. If technology corrected and some of that money moved across sectors, he thought energy could outperform technology during the correction. That depended on the rotation developing; he was waiting for the market to show more.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2024-06-21 episode.

What would make Nicoski take the rotation more seriously?

He wanted several days of follow-through. Stocks rising on a single day when technology fell were an early observation, but their downtrends had not yet changed.

Link to this answer

Why did he question the consumer-strength argument?

He saw large differences within consumer groups. Gains in Costco and Walmart did not answer the weakness he saw in discretionary purchases such as boats and recreational vehicles. He wanted broader participation within a group.

Link to this answer

Which natural-resource stocks did he favor?

He said his firm had turned positive on aluminum stocks about four months earlier, naming Alcoa and Century Aluminum, and still liked that group. He separately said he did not favor the broader materials sector at the time.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .