Takeaways
#- Sohn described a crowded thematic-fund market in which closures had exceeded launches in the universe he studied.
- He viewed spot Bitcoin products as competitors for money that might otherwise enter thematic funds.
- Healthcare’s poor relative performance and outflows interested him as a contrarian idea, without establishing a repaired trend.
- He tolerated broad-market consolidation but would be more concerned by new equal-weight lows alongside rising capitalization-weighted indexes.
Todd Sohn saw a supply problem in thematic ETFs. Fund providers had launched products around electric vehicles, cybersecurity and other growth stories, but the number of available funds had outrun the money investors were willing to put into them.
Joining the June 28, 2024 Morning Show, he told Spencer Israel, JC Parets and Steve Strazza that closures had exceeded launches over the preceding two years in the thematic universe he was studying. Smaller products were struggling in an increasingly crowded market.
A theme needed more than a compelling name
Sohn understood the appeal of a fund that crossed conventional sector boundaries to capture a developing trend. His concern was whether another product offered enough to justify an allocation.
Many thematic funds still leaned heavily toward technology and growth stocks. If an investor already owned familiar large companies through SPY or QQQ, he questioned the need for another fund containing similar names. The established products also offered the size and liquidity that mattered to larger positions.
He linked the wave of competing launches to the earlier success of innovation-focused funds. Other issuers had followed with their own versions, leaving many products competing for the same investor interest. He expected that pressure to persist.
A market decline could make the economics harder. Falling holdings would reduce assets under management, and investor withdrawals could compound the reduction. Sohn presented that as a vulnerability for smaller funds, without predicting that a particular correction was imminent.
Bitcoin products competed for the same allocation
Spot Bitcoin products added another choice for investors considering a thematic or alternative allocation. Sohn used a hypothetical portfolio slice to explain the competition: money that might previously have gone into an electric-vehicle fund or cryptocurrency-mining stocks could instead go directly into a spot Bitcoin product.
He saw two possible sources of demand. A rising Bitcoin price could attract investors chasing performance, while portfolio models might gradually introduce allocations of their own. The second was his expectation for how adoption could develop over time.
The discussion also distinguished assets remaining in a fund from money flowing out of it. Grayscale Bitcoin Trust still held substantial assets, even after large withdrawals. Sohn saw that persistence and the outflows as compatible observations; the remaining size did not erase the money that had already left.
Healthcare offered a different question
When Israel asked about healthcare outflows, Sohn explained why the weakness had caught his attention. In his work, the sector combined unusually poor relative performance with substantial investor withdrawals. He was looking for ideas beyond the technology holdings that had already worked.
He did not endorse healthcare’s relative trend. His interest was contrarian: the degree of underperformance and selling made the sector worth considering for a small initial allocation. He also distinguished the capitalization-weighted healthcare index, supported by some large winners, from the sector’s weaker relative position.
Later, when Parets pressed him for a trade idea, Sohn returned to healthcare and suggested biotechnology as a more focused area to examine. That preference was separate from claiming the whole sector had already regained leadership.
Consolidation was still acceptable
Sohn remained constructive on the wider market. Several important groups had spent months moving sideways while technology continued higher. He could accept that consolidation after the preceding advance.
His concern would increase if the equal-weight market started making new lows while the capitalization-weighted index kept rising. The hosts distinguished that potential deterioration from the sideways conditions they were discussing.
Small-cap selection required similar care. A chart excluding banks from the Russell 2000 did not remove the index’s weakness, and the hosts said a version excluding both banks and biotechnology told a similar story. Sohn favored an active manager who could identify stronger individual businesses while the broader small-cap index remained unsettled.
Questions and answers
#Questions about the original 2024-06-28 episode.
Why did Sohn question the need for some thematic ETFs?
Many held technology and growth names investors could already own through larger funds. He questioned whether another overlapping product justified an allocation in a crowded market.
How did Bitcoin products affect his analysis?
He thought spot Bitcoin products could attract part of the same alternative or thematic allocation, competing with funds built around electric vehicles or cryptocurrency-related stocks.
What attracted him to healthcare?
His research showed large outflows and unusually poor relative performance. That made it a contrarian area to investigate, although he did not endorse its relative trend.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .