Takeaways

#
  • Harrison said almost 90% of S&P 500 stocks had made a three-month high more recently than a three-month low.
  • He viewed equal-weight underperformance partly as the effect of large growth companies leading the cap-weighted index.
  • The HYG chart corrected an initial impression of a breakout. The fund remained below February’s high without breaking down.

The Dow industrials and the Dow transports were telling different stories in March 2024. The industrial average had cleared its old highs. The transports hadn’t. On the March 11 Morning Show, the hosts could make a case for watching that divergence and an equally good case for asking how much weight one lagging group deserved. Semiconductors and homebuilders, for example, were already participating in the advance.

Austin Harrison of Grindstone Intelligence approached the problem one stock at a time. Almost 90% of the S&P 500, he said, had made a three-month high more recently than a three-month low. A stock didn’t have to be setting a high that morning to count. What mattered was which extreme it had visited last.

Why a shorter list of new highs wasn’t enough

The number of stocks making 52-week highs had peaked in December. Harrison thought the burst of buying that month made a tough comparison. After a quieter period, he had seen new highs begin to multiply again. Meanwhile, the count of stocks falling to six-month lows had failed to exceed even its mid-January reading.

Looking for 52-week lows alone would have set a high bar for spotting trouble while the major indexes were near records. The three- and six-month readings let him look for deterioration sooner. A reversal back below the Dow’s January 2022 high would also have put his outlook in question. He was watching for similar failed breakouts in the S&P 500 and Nasdaq.

Weighting changed the answer

The equal-weight S&P 500 had lagged its capitalization-weighted counterpart. To Harrison, that comparison told investors more about which stocks led than whether most stocks were falling. The biggest growth companies carried much larger weights in the conventional index. When value stocks had led in 2022, equal weighting had looked better.

Harrison did see a reason for technology to pause. The sector index had reached a level he measured from its 2022 decline, while its momentum was no longer keeping up with price. He allowed for the sector to move sideways rather than suffer another large drawdown. A change in leadership could give value stocks room to outperform. For smaller companies, financials would matter more and large technology names less because the sector weights were different.

A second look at the bond chart

Harrison thought the high-yield corporate bond fund HYG had broken out. When the hosts put the chart up, they found it was still below its February high. He acknowledged the correction. The narrower point held: HYG hadn’t broken down, and credit spreads weren’t showing the retreat from risk he would expect in a deteriorating market.

For an allocator working over weeks or months, the question was what would justify changing a portfolio. Harrison could name evidence that would get his attention: failed index breakouts, more stocks setting new lows and weakness in high-yield debt. On March 11, the absence of new lows carried more weight in his assessment than the transports’ failure to make a new high.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2024-03-11 episode.

How did Harrison measure participation beyond the major indexes?

He compared the dates of each stock’s most recent three-month high and low. He also tracked whether more stocks were falling to six-month lows.

Link to this answer

What would have challenged his bullish outlook?

A failed breakout below the Dow’s January 2022 high, similar failures in other major indexes, expanding new lows or weakness in high-yield bonds would have warranted another look.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .