Takeaways
#- Hurley thought the persistence of a smaller new-lows warning deserved more attention than he had initially given it.
- He combined breadth deterioration with the maturity of the advance when considering less aggressive portfolio models.
- The VIX improvement he had hoped to see on Monday had not materialized.
- A lack of new highs mattered differently during a trading range than during a subsequent upside breakout.
Mike Hurley wished he had given a small December breadth warning more weight. By the March 11, 2025 Morning Show, the stock market was breaking support, and a signal he described as a baby fall day looked more consequential.
He joined Steve Strazza and Grant Hawkridge to examine why the warning had been difficult to judge in real time.
The warning was smaller than earlier examples
Hurley compared the recent market with earlier periods in his research. Some had produced more than 700 new 52-week lows before the market ultimately peaked. The recent reading he highlighted was about 250, a much less striking number.
He admitted that he had partly talked himself out of treating it as a major warning. The stronger clue, in retrospect, was that the weakness persisted for roughly five weeks. It was not just a brief disturbance that disappeared while leadership recovered.
Hawkridge had also noticed a change in December. His new-highs-minus-new-lows work had shifted after a long stretch of healthier readings. He and Hurley agreed that the smaller signal was easier to dismiss than the dramatic examples they remembered from past cycles.
Hurley’s concern was the combination of weak internals and a market still near its highs. A rising index normally looked healthier to him when more stocks participated. Here, the underlying list was beginning to tell a different story.
Cycle maturity changed how he weighed the divergence
Hurley placed the warning alongside a study that compared the price gains and duration of earlier bull markets. In his framework, the advance from the October 2022 low was mature enough that deteriorating breadth deserved closer attention.
He was not certain the final high had already occurred. Another push was possible. His response did not require him to identify the exact top first: he thought it was time to move client models toward less aggressive allocations.
That also explained his use of the seasonal language. A fall day helped him decide when to take divergences more seriously. He said similar-looking discrepancies could appear earlier in a bull market without stopping its advance. The surrounding market conditions affected how he interpreted them.
A volatility signal had not yet delivered the relief he wanted
Hurley watched the VIX against its five-day simple moving average as one way to judge whether a panic was easing. He did not try to predict the exact level at which volatility would peak.
Instead, he looked for the VIX to move back below that short average after a surge. He had hoped the preceding Friday’s action might lead to that confirmation on Monday. Monday’s renewed selling failed to give him the improvement he wanted.
His broader assessment remained mixed. FedEx looked weak to him and mattered because of its economic sensitivity. IBM and some gold stocks looked better. He thought traders could find opportunities on either side, while longer-term investors had reason to be more careful after a strong two-year advance.
New highs needed to expand when prices broke out
Hawkridge asked about the difference between daily breadth data and Hurley’s usual weekly approach. Hurley described a pattern from 1998 that he considered useful: new highs could fade naturally while an index moved sideways, but they should revive when the index broke upward.
In the historical example he discussed, that expansion never arrived. He saw a resemblance in the recent data, where new highs had faded and then failed to regain momentum. The warning depended on what participation did as prices changed, rather than on the decline in new highs during a trading range alone.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2025-03-11 episode.
Why did the smaller December warning matter to Hurley?
Although the new-lows reading was less dramatic than earlier examples, the weakness persisted for about five weeks while the market was near its highs.
Had he identified a definite market top?
No. He allowed for another push higher, but thought the market’s maturity and weakening internals justified less aggressive client models.
How did he use the VIX?
He watched for it to fall back below its five-day simple moving average after a surge as evidence that panic might be easing. The Monday improvement he had hoped for had not arrived.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .