Takeaways
#- Brown distinguished XLK’s capped benchmark from the broader sector index when evaluating the long-term technology-relative chart.
- He and Parets agreed that recent relative weakness remained visible despite the different long-term comparisons.
- Brown favored some Europe and China exposure while resisting a multi-decade forecast based on a few months of outperformance.
- His healthcare adjustment reduced an underweight toward the benchmark before he was willing to make a larger positive bet.
Scott Brown agreed that technology looked weak when he joined the March 19, 2025 Morning Show. He disagreed with the chart being used to explain why.
JC Parets had been watching technology’s performance relative to the S&P 500 approach the highs from the dot-com era and then roll over. Brown’s objection was specific: the chart used XLK, and the fund’s weighting rules had produced a different history from the broader S&P 500 information technology sector index.
Two technology measures told different long-term stories
Brown pointed to Nvidia’s relatively small weight in XLK during part of 2024 as an example of why the fund could diverge from a market-cap-weighted sector measure. He argued that the index comparison had already exceeded the old relative highs, so the apparent rejection was less exact than the ETF chart suggested.
The hosts pulled up both versions. Parets acknowledged that the S&P 500 information technology sector ratio had moved above the previous cycle’s highs, while the ETF ratio showed the rollover near those levels.
The distinction began with the benchmark. XLK followed the Technology Select Sector Index, which applied constituent-weight caps. That was a different measure from the uncapped sector comparison under discussion. S&P’s contemporaneous explanation of the 2024 rebalance described how its capping process had reduced Nvidia’s weight. S&P Dow Jones Indices’ June 2024 explanation.
Brown’s practical concern was that investors needed to understand the rules behind the fund they owned. A shared technology label did not make every chart interchangeable.
The recent weakness remained visible in both
The disagreement did not turn Brown bullish on technology. He wanted to zoom in on the recent trend, where the sector was making multi-month relative lows. Parets agreed that the shorter-term deterioration appeared in both versions of the comparison.
Brown also described weakness in XLK’s absolute price chart. He expected overhead resistance after the decline and noted that its 21-day moving average had moved below its 200-day average. He treated that as evidence of a changed trend, rather than a reason to buy simply because prices had fallen.
His own trend score examined the slopes of one-, three-, six- and twelve-month averages. He said technology had recently been the only sector with all four sloping downward. The precise relationship with a decades-old high was secondary to that broad deterioration.
Overseas strength deserved exposure without a fifteen-year forecast
Brown was more receptive to Europe and China. He thought the rally differed from some earlier periods of overseas outperformance because it was not explained entirely by a growth-versus-value rotation.
He was still cautious about extrapolation. Several months of relative improvement did not persuade him to declare another fifteen years of leadership. He would follow the trends that were present and preferred some exposure to those markets over U.S. technology, while recognizing their volatility.
The dollar was another condition he watched. Its decline had helped the international move, and Brown thought a further break around the 100–101 area would matter to maintaining the pace. He did not assume that next leg would occur.
Healthcare showed how a change in view could be gradual
Brown described healthcare as an example of adjusting exposure before becoming outright bullish. Its prolonged relative weakness had attracted his attention, but he did not want to jump straight from an underweight to an overweight while the trend remained poor.
Instead, he had moved his XLV exposure closer to the benchmark. He compared reducing an underweight with taking some profits on a short: it lowered the size of the existing negative bet.
He also distinguished healthcare’s relative improvement from its absolute return. Outperforming the S&P 500 had not necessarily translated into a large gain for someone holding the sector. That distinction mattered for the benchmark-relative portfolios he was discussing.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2025-03-19 episode.
Why did Brown challenge the XLK chart?
He said the ETF’s weighting rules made its long-term relative chart differ from the broader technology sector index. The index version had already exceeded the old highs that appeared to cap the ETF comparison.
Did that distinction make him bullish on technology?
No. He emphasized recent multi-month relative lows, weakness in the absolute chart and declining trend measures. Parets agreed that the nearer-term deterioration appeared in both comparisons.
How did Brown adjust his healthcare exposure?
He reduced his underweight by moving XLV closer to its benchmark weight. He did not want to become overweight simply because the sector had suffered a prolonged decline.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .