Takeaways
#- Dwyer expected earnings growth outside the largest stocks to broaden; the sector moves reflected that expectation ahead of company results.
- His tactical indicators and managers' positioning made him reluctant to chase the index even with a favorable intermediate-term outlook.
- Parets had bought financials earlier and was finding more attractive entries in materials and energy by March.
Tony Dwyer expected more companies to contribute to earnings growth in 2024. That made him optimistic about stocks over the intermediate term. It didn't make him want to buy the S&P 500 after the run it had already enjoyed. As he told JC Parets on the March 21 Morning Show, waiting for a better entry had already cost him a few percentage points of upside. He was willing to live with that.
What the rotation said about earnings
Parets saw energy and materials starting to catch up. He wanted to know whether to stick with the stocks that had led for years or start looking among the laggards. Dwyer approached the question through profits. The largest technology-related companies had accounted for an unusually large share of earnings growth, he said. Investors had good reason to give them most of their attention.
His expectation for the rest of the year was that other businesses would contribute more. If a wider group of companies could grow profits, investors would have a reason to own them beyond the fact that their shares had underperformed.
Parets asked whether the improvement in energy and materials meant the earnings shift had arrived. Dwyer made a small but consequential correction: prices were moving on the expectation of broader earnings growth. The next set of company results still had to deliver it. He also distinguished the pace of a change in fundamentals from trading flows, which could move prices from one day to the next.
The cost of getting the entry wrong
Dwyer followed measures that included the share of stocks above their 10- and 50-day moving averages, the change in the VIX and a weekly S&P 500 momentum indicator. He also tracked how aggressively active managers were positioned. In his reading, those measures pointed to a market where enthusiasm was already high.
He offered a hypothetical trade-off. A buyer might be right about another 5% of upside and still sit through a 10% correction soon afterward. An even smaller decline posed a practical problem: after chasing a rally, would he be able to hold his position through a 2% down day? He had more conviction buying a sharp pullback than trying to make that decision with fresh losses on the screen.
Parets was already buying elsewhere
Parets had a different answer to the entry problem. He and his team had bought financial stocks aggressively early in the fourth quarter. By March, financials were testing former highs, and he liked that purchase less than he had months earlier. Materials and energy stocks now offered entries he preferred. He could change what he owned without first deciding when the index would fall.
Dwyer welcomed the distinction. The biggest companies had such a large weight in the S&P 500 that an index quote could obscure the shift the two were discussing. For Dwyer, the test of whether that rotation could last was whether companies outside the leaders began to contribute more of the market's earnings growth.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2024-03-21 episode.
Why did Dwyer expect a wider group of stocks to attract buyers?
He expected companies outside the Magnificent Seven to contribute more earnings growth. In his view, improving profit prospects could give investors a reason to allocate money beyond the previous leaders.
What made him prefer a pullback?
Participation, momentum and active managers' positioning already looked extended to him. He acknowledged missing some of the rally, but thought a lower entry would make it easier to stay with his intermediate-term view.
How did Parets put his own view into practice?
He said his team had bought financial stocks aggressively early in the fourth quarter. In March he preferred opportunities in materials and energy to buying those financials again near former highs.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .