Takeaways
#- Sohn saw closures as evidence that investor demand had already weakened substantially, rather than a signal that Chinese stocks had bottomed.
- Parets described a partially built FXI call position; lower call orders and a potential put sale were still conditional.
- Sohn’s 50/50 EWJ and DXJ example split the currency exposure of a Japan allocation.
An ETF closure takes longer than a bad trading day. An issuer has to decide a product no longer justifies its place in the lineup, get approval and wind it down. By the time several issuers were making that decision about China, Todd Sohn thought investors had already said quite a lot with their money.
On the March 5 Morning Show, he pointed to the contrast between specialized China products shutting down and demand for emerging-market funds that excluded the country. Global X’s January filing illustrates the scale of the retreat: its board elected to liquidate China funds covering financials, industrials, energy and several other sectors.
A tactical bounce was a different bet
Sohn understood the business decision. A niche fund with little investor interest is difficult to sustain. What interested him as a market observer was when those decisions arrived. Bad headlines about China were already common, investors were finding ways to leave it out of portfolios, and issuers were acting on that loss of demand. An investor looking for a rebound had less optimism to contend with than one arriving during a wave of new fund launches.
JC Parets described a position in long-dated calls on the iShares China Large-Cap ETF, FXI. His team had put on about a third of the desired position and left orders to buy more calls at lower prices. Selling puts was a possibility if further weakness made their premiums more attractive. Those additional steps still depended on the market.
Sohn could see the rationale for using options to pursue a bounce. He remained skeptical of a long-term China allocation and emphasized how volatile a direct purchase could be. There was evidence of healthier markets elsewhere even as investors gave up on Chinese shares: the hosts noted a fresh 52-week high in emerging markets excluding China. India and Taiwan mattered to that comparison. Writing off the whole asset class would have missed the move outside its most controversial market.
Japan raised a question about the yen
In Japan, the direction of investor interest was almost the reverse. Stocks had reached a much-discussed high and money was coming in. Yet Sohn thought the flows remained well short of the excitement he remembered around 2012 and 2013. Industrials, consumer discretionary stocks and financials also gave the Japanese market a different mix from the technology-heavy S&P 500.
For a U.S. investor, liking Japanese equities left a second decision unresolved: how much exposure to take to the yen. Sohn said a strengthening yen could favor an unhedged fund, but he saw too many variables to want a portfolio to depend entirely on that call. Asked to choose between EWJ and the currency-hedged DXJ, he described splitting a Japan allocation equally between them. It let him participate in Japanese shares without putting the whole position on one side of the currency question.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2024-03-05 episode.
Why did Sohn pay attention to ETF closures?
By the time issuers shut their funds, weak demand had persisted long enough to prompt a business decision. He treated that as information about investor sentiment.
Why did Sohn suggest holding both EWJ and DXJ?
EWJ leaves the investor exposed to the yen, while DXJ hedges currency exposure. Pairing them reduced the importance of making the right call on the yen when the main interest was Japanese stocks.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .