Takeaways
#- Elfenbein kept annual stock selections in place for 12 months while continuing to research companies throughout the year.
- HEICO, Intuit and Moody's illustrated his search for businesses with strong positions in their markets.
- Miller Industries' weaker outlook and McGrath's failed acquisition showed the difficulties that could arise during a long holding period.
- He evaluated dividend histories and management's reliability rather than beginning with the highest yield.
Eddy Elfenbein chose his stocks on a different schedule from the traders hosting the May 29, 2025 Morning Show. He reviewed his selections at year-end, then kept the list in place for 12 months. Research continued throughout that holding period.
His conversation with Spencer Israel and Steve Strazza centered on the businesses behind those selections. He wanted companies with strong positions in their markets, consistent earnings and management whose explanations held up against subsequent results. A disappointing quarter could fit that approach; an explanation he could not trust was another matter.
HEICO showed why he valued a specialized business
Elfenbein highlighted HEICO after a strong earnings report. He described an aircraft-parts business serving customers who wanted to keep expensive equipment operating for as long as possible. Replacement parts had to meet strict requirements, and he valued HEICO's experience navigating that work.
Strazza saw a breakout in the stock. Elfenbein supplied the business history, including a mistake of his own: he had sold HEICO several years earlier because he thought its price was too high, then watched it continue higher. He eventually bought it again.
The experience helped explain his preference for companies that could sustain their position over time. He was willing to study valuation, but he also wanted to understand what kept customers returning and competitors from easily taking their place.
Intuit was another example. Elfenbein liked the recent earnings report and remained constructive on the business despite concerns that a government tax-filing option could hurt TurboTax. The discussion also covered QuickBooks, Credit Karma and Mailchimp, giving the company several businesses to evaluate beyond the annual tax season.
Moody's fitted the same search for an entrenched market position. Elfenbein discussed both its ratings-related operations and analytics business. When Strazza asked whether he deliberately looked for companies dominating their fields, he said that was central to his selection process.
A long holding period did not make every update welcome
Miller Industries provided a less comfortable example. Elfenbein liked the tow-truck manufacturer and described how earlier investment in capacity had eventually contributed to a strong year.
Its newer earnings outlook had disappointed him. He pointed to chassis-delivery issues and said the guidance was weaker than he had expected. He remained interested in the company while acknowledging that the update had challenged his expectations.
Strazza separately identified roughly $47 as an area where a trader could define risk. That chart level served a different purpose from Elfenbein's annual stock-selection process.
McGrath RentCorp presented another test of patience. A planned acquisition had dragged on before falling apart. Elfenbein decided to retain the modular-building rental company for 2025, expecting a rebound after the stalled transaction. By the broadcast, he was pleased with the progress, while remembering how difficult the extended wait had been.
Management's record mattered more than a large dividend
Elfenbein did not make a high dividend yield the starting point for selecting stocks. He preferred a history of steady increases, while allowing that a company might have a reasonable explanation for interrupting that pattern. A very large yield could also be asking investors to accept more risk.
The hosts discussed his approach through CWS, the AdvisorShares Focused Equity ETF. He accepted growth at a reasonable price as a useful description, rather than treating the portfolio as strictly value-oriented.
By late May, he was already considering possible changes for the next annual review. Names tended to come together in the third and fourth quarters, but the work ran all year. He compared what management had promised with what actually happened and watched whether companies stayed with their stated plans.
He could accept a forecast for a difficult quarter or year. What he wanted was enough consistency between the explanation and the result to keep trusting the business through the holding period.
Questions and answers
#Questions about the original 2025-05-29 episode.
How often did Elfenbein change his stock selections?
He said he reviewed the list at year-end and kept his selections for the next 12 months. He researched throughout the year, with potential changes often taking shape in the third and fourth quarters.
Why did HEICO interest him?
He valued its specialized aircraft-parts business and experience meeting demanding requirements. He also described selling it earlier over valuation concerns, then returning to the stock after that decision proved disappointing.
What did he want to learn from management updates?
He compared what companies had said with what they subsequently delivered. A difficult quarter or year was not automatically disqualifying; he wanted explanations that remained credible and consistent with the company's plan.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .